Skip to main content
Jon Christensen
Guelph Council Record

Committee of the Whole · July 03, 2024 · Item 10.2

Lobbyist Registry By-law, included as Attachment-1 to report 2024-294, dated July 3, 2024, be approved. That the Lobbyist Code of Conduct…

Main motion under the agenda item Lobbyist Registry By-law - 2024-294

Carried (12 to 0)

12 in favour, 0 against — unanimous

What was voted on

The motion in its exact words, as recorded in the minutes.

That the Lobbyist Registry By-law, included as Attachment-1 to report 2024-294, dated July 3, 2024, be approved. That the Lobbyist Code of Conduct, included as Attachment-2 to report 2024-294, dated July 3, 2024, be approved. That Suzanne Craig be appointed as the City of Guelph Lobbyist Registrar. That the Mayor and City Clerk be authorized to execute an agreement to contract the services of Suzanne Craig to act as the City of Guelph Lobbyist Registrar.

Moved by Councillor Downer, seconded by Councillor Klassen.

How the room voted

In favour (12)

  • Allt
  • Billings
  • Busuttil
  • Caron
  • Caton
  • Chew
  • Downer
  • Goller
  • Guthrie
  • Klassen
  • O'Rourke
  • Richardson

Who spoke to it

Dylan McMahon, Acting General Manager, City Clerk's Office/City Clerk, presented.

What council was given

The staff reports and correspondence attached to this item. The summaries are written automatically, so you can tell what a document is without opening a ninety-page PDF.

A summary is this site’s description of a document, not the City’s. Open the document before relying on one.

What was said

946 words from the meeting recording, transcribed automatically. Times are from the start of the recording.

Read the debate(click to open)

4:33:07So we are on to the lobbyist registry.

4:33:11The bylaw is now being presented from our acting general

4:33:16manager of clerks.

4:33:17I will turn it over to you, Dylan,

4:33:18and take us through how this will work.

4:33:23Thank you very much, Mr. Mayor.

4:33:24Good evening, members of council.

4:33:26It's a pleasure for me to be here today in a different chair

4:33:28than normal to present to you Guelph's lobbyist registry

4:33:31bylaw.

4:33:33The lobbyist registry is a significant addition

4:33:35to Guelph's existing transparency and accountability

4:33:37program.

4:33:38That includes right now our commitment

4:33:39to open meetings, the council code of conduct,

4:33:42the council gift registry, the declarations of pecuniary interest

4:33:45registry, the closed meeting investigator,

4:33:48and the integrity commissioner.

4:33:50Members of council will remember that we presented a lobbyist

4:33:53registry framework in April.

4:33:55The bylaw before you today is largely

4:33:57consistent with that framework with a few specific changes

4:34:00that are noted and expanded on in the report.

4:34:03Since April, we've met with stakeholders

4:34:05from the not-for-profit and the for-profit sectors

4:34:08to talk about the lobbyist registry.

4:34:11When we talked to stakeholders, there

4:34:13was one piece of feedback that was unanimous.

4:34:15It didn't matter whether you were in the not-for-profit sector

4:34:17or the for-profit, whether you loved

4:34:19the idea of a lobbyist registry or perhaps you were a little bit

4:34:22more hesitant.

4:34:24And that was if this is the direction

4:34:25that we're taking as a city, to make the lobbyist registry

4:34:28bylaw as easy to understand and implement as possible

4:34:32and to make the lobbyist registry tool as easy to use

4:34:36as possible.

4:34:37To that end, I'm really happy to be presenting what we believe

4:34:39is the simplest lobbyist registry

4:34:42in the province of Ontario.

4:34:46We've designed the registry to make the process of registering

4:34:49and filing returns as easy to understand as possible.

4:34:53And the registry tool, which is being built in-house

4:34:56by the city's IT department, is focused on making sure

4:34:59that the tool itself is user-friendly and hassle-free.

4:35:03Registering as a lobbyist in Guelph and then

4:35:05filing a return will take a couple of minutes.

4:35:07You'll be able to do it from any device, on any platform,

4:35:10anywhere you happen to be.

4:35:12We've designed the system this way

4:35:14because we know that lobbying is a feature

4:35:16of a healthy democracy, not a symptom of an unhealthy one.

4:35:20Lobbying at the local level is about residents

4:35:23having direct access to senior city staff and elected

4:35:26officials on city council.

4:35:29We've got some big issues to solve as a community,

4:35:31and we know that we need everybody working together

4:35:34to solve those issues.

4:35:35Whether it's a for-profit business, a charity,

4:35:38a not-for-profit, we don't want to limit anybody's access

4:35:41to public office holders in Guelph.

4:35:44The purpose of the registry, then,

4:35:45is not to disincentivize or limit the effectiveness

4:35:48or amount of lobbying, but to provide the public

4:35:51with transparent information, transparent access

4:35:54to information about lobbying.

4:35:56Specifically, we want to provide access to information

4:35:59where we have lobbyists lobbying for specific policy outcomes

4:36:03where they have a financial stake in those policy outcomes.

4:36:07This is actually very similar to the disclosure

4:36:10of pecuniary interest registry that council's

4:36:12already familiar with.

4:36:13When a member of council files a disclosure that goes online

4:36:17on a registry, it's publicly available and searchable,

4:36:19the lobbyist registry establishes a very similar requirement

4:36:23for lobbyists.

4:36:24The key difference being, of course,

4:36:25after a member of council files, you

4:36:27can't participate or vote on a matter.

4:36:29When a lobbyist files, it's just about transparency.

4:36:32They're welcome to keep lobbying or keep

4:36:33working toward their specific policy outcome after they file.

4:36:40The lobbyist registry itself is enforced by a lobbyist registrar.

4:36:44The registrar is responsible first and foremost

4:36:47for providing advice, education, and training

4:36:49to members of the public, potential lobbyists, to staff,

4:36:52and to members of city council.

4:36:54They also have a role to play in conducting investigations

4:36:57regarding alleged contraventions of the bylaw.

4:37:00We're very happy to be recommending the appointment

4:37:02of Suzanne Craig as a golf's lobbyist registrar.

4:37:04Miss Craig is currently the lobbyist registrar

4:37:07for the city of Vaughan and is acted as an integrity

4:37:09commissioner for more than 20 different Ontario

4:37:12municipalities.

4:37:14Pending council's approval of the bylaw

4:37:16at the end of the month, the lobbyist registry

4:37:18will come into effect on October 1 with enforcement provision

4:37:22suspended until January 1, 2025.

4:37:25Bugging in September, there'll be a communications and education

4:37:28campaign to ensure that members of the public, potential lobbyists,

4:37:32staff, and city council understand the bylaw

4:37:34and the obligations that they have under the bylaw.

4:37:38Were a violation to occur before January 2025,

4:37:42the lobbyist would simply be receiving a reminder

4:37:44from the city clerk's office with the support of the registrar

4:37:47and an offer for any support or education or training

4:37:50that might be helpful.

4:37:52That brings me to the end of my presentation,

4:37:54but I'm, of course, happy to answer any questions.

4:37:56And I do want to thank Garrett Meads and Andrew Sandor, who

4:37:59are both at the center table here,

4:38:01who played a critical role in writing this report and the bylaw.

4:38:08Well done.

4:38:11Thank you very much.

4:38:14Why don't we start with at least tabling the recommendations?

4:38:19Councillor Downer, Councillor Colassen will second.

4:38:21Lots of hands went up.

4:38:22I know.

4:38:22Even the ones I wasn't looking at.

4:38:24So we're good there.

4:38:26Is there any questions at this time?

4:38:29Nope.

4:38:30This is easy.

4:38:32Here we go.

4:38:32I'm going to call the vote.

4:38:34Is anyone against the lobbyist registry?

4:38:38unanimous.

4:38:40I'm so sorry you had to stick around for the entire thing.

4:38:45That's unanimous.

4:38:46Perfect.

4:38:47Thank you so much.

4:38:48We are on our last topic.

Automatic transcription is imperfect. Treat quotes as a guide and check the recording before relying on exact wording.

Check this against the City’s official minutes

The motion, the vote and the debate come from the City of Guelph’s published record, reproduced rather than interpreted. The document summaries above are the exception: those words were written for this site.

See the rest of this meeting