City Council · February 27, 2024 · Item 9.2
Staff to reconstruct the Wyndham Street North corridor as follows: Wyndham Street – Carden Street to Woolwich Street as one lane of traffic in each direction…
Main motion under the agenda item Wyndham Street North Cross Section and St George’s Square Intersection - 2024-37
Carried (13 to 0)
13 in favour, 0 against — unanimous
What was voted on
The motion in its exact words, as recorded in the minutes.
That Council direct staff to reconstruct the Wyndham Street North corridor as follows: Wyndham Street – Carden Street to Woolwich Street as one lane of traffic in each direction with parallel parking and separated unidirectional bike paths along both sides of the road with flexibility to accommodate the seasonal patio program; and, St. George’s Square as an offset intersection similar to existing conditions with operational improvements and separated unidirectional bike paths.
Moved by Councillor Allt, seconded by Councillor Goller.
How the room voted
In favour (13)
- Allt
- Billings
- Busuttil
- Caron
- Caton
- Chew
- Downer
- Gibson
- Goller
- Guthrie
- Klassen
- O'Rourke
- Richardson
Who spoke to it
The following delegate spoke: Adam Donaldson The following delegate did not speak: Chuck Nash
What council was given
The staff reports and correspondence attached to this item. The summaries are written automatically, so you can tell what a document is without opening a ninety-page PDF.
- Wyndham Street North Cross Section and St George’s Square Intersection - 2024-37.pdf
Staff ask Council to endorse how Wyndham Street North between Carden and Woolwich will be rebuilt: one traffic lane each way, parallel parking, and separated one-way bike lanes on both sides, with room for seasonal patios. St. George's Square would stay an offset intersection with operational improvements and separated bike lanes. The choice follows summer 2023 consultation, a September 27, 2023 open house and an online survey.
- Attachment-1 St. George’s Square Reconstruction Options .pdf
- Attachment-2 Recommended Wyndham Street Cross Section.pdf
- Attachment-3 Recommended St. George’s Square Intersection.pdf
- Attachment-4 Seasonal Patio Program.pdf
- Attachment-5 Downtown Renewal - Journey to Revitalization.pdf
- Attachment 6 - DTIRP Wyndham Cooridor Presentation.pdf
A summary is this site’s description of a document, not the City’s. Open the document before relying on one.
What was said
4,694 words from the meeting recording, transcribed automatically. Times are from the start of the recording.
Read the debate(click to open)
2:15:49We have a couple delegations up for the first item for discussion.
2:15:54We have our first delegation in person.
2:15:57Adam Donaldson, this is in regards
2:15:59to the Windham Street North Cross section and St. George's
2:16:02Square intersection.
2:16:03And that's in person.
2:16:05And then we have one more, Chuck Nash, the Downtown Golf
2:16:08Business Association chair will be joining us by telephone.
2:16:12Adam, you know the drill.
2:16:14No more than five minutes.
2:16:15Chime at four minutes and 30 seconds.
2:16:18I'll turn it over to you.
2:16:19Thank you.
2:16:19Good evening.
2:16:20I'm here to speak on behalf of a group of people
2:16:23that use St. George's Square who were not mentioned
2:16:26or represented at Committee of the Whole earlier this month.
2:16:28And that is golf transit users.
2:16:30We're still here.
2:16:31We're still angry.
2:16:32And we are still waiting for this council
2:16:34to deliver on its promise and the promise of your predecessors
2:16:38to deliver transit that is fast, fair, and frequent.
2:16:42Came as no surprise to me that when
2:16:43I was consulting the reports and materials included
2:16:46under Windham Street North Cross section and St. George's
2:16:48Square intersection, that there was hardly
2:16:51any mention of transit at all.
2:16:53Only vague inferences that transit vehicles
2:16:55would be among those that would continue to have access
2:16:58to the new two-lane version of Upper Windham.
2:17:03However, St. George's Square is more than just a spot
2:17:05for buses to pass through on their way
2:17:07to and from Guelph Central Station.
2:17:10Since this is something that council is unlikely to realize
2:17:12from their own experiences, I must note
2:17:14that a number of routes stop in St. George's Square
2:17:18or they allow transit riders the rare convenience and choice
2:17:22in how they access the system.
2:17:24The number three stops in St. George's Square.
2:17:27The number 10 stops in St. George's Square.
2:17:30The number 11 stops in St. George's Square.
2:17:34The number 12 stops in St. George's Square.
2:17:37The number 13 stops in St. George's Square.
2:17:40And the number 20 stops in St. George's Square.
2:17:43It allows many users to transfer buses
2:17:45or access the northern end of downtown
2:17:48without having to backtrack from Central Station.
2:17:50And it would be a shame if disconnectivity were
2:17:53to be lost in the name of what I consider
2:17:55unhelpful virtue signaling.
2:17:58I also have extraordinary doubts
2:18:00that this plan will maintain the flow of traffic
2:18:02by keeping two lanes open while preserving on-street parking.
2:18:05I was traveling on Guelph Transit on the weekend
2:18:09and the bus was stopped four times
2:18:12between Norfolk and Central Station.
2:18:15Stuck behind a car, sitting on a parking space,
2:18:19waiting for one person to leave so that they could drive in.
2:18:23And this was even while the parkades
2:18:24did mostly empty.
2:18:25It was on Saturday, so it wasn't a Guelph Storm day.
2:18:30Downtown Guelph does not have the parking problem
2:18:32that many people think it does.
2:18:33And even if it did, they don't promote their options.
2:18:36Transit buses arrive in downtown Guelph
2:18:39from all corners of the city at least twice an hour.
2:18:43But this never seemed to warrant a mention
2:18:46on the Downtown Guelph Business Association's own website.
2:18:49So I'm forced to wonder,
2:18:51why is downtown so hostile to transit
2:18:54that brings people to their businesses?
2:18:58As it stands today, trying to board a bus
2:18:59and saying Georgia Square is an occasional
2:19:01excruciating exercise.
2:19:03I have sometimes witnessed people parking in the bus stop
2:19:06in complete indifference and callousness to the fact
2:19:09that it is properly signed.
2:19:11And there are usually two or three people
2:19:12waiting for the bus.
2:19:15It wasn't always this way.
2:19:16Over a decade ago, St. George's Square
2:19:17was the rallying point for all Guelph Transit buses.
2:19:21But now there's only one lonely shelter
2:19:23to remind you that this is a place
2:19:24where you can get on and off a transit bus.
2:19:27Mostly it's just another open street
2:19:28ready to receive as much car traffic
2:19:30as we can shove down it.
2:19:33Canadians to be profoundly disappointing that this city,
2:19:36which faints to be sensitive to environmental concerns
2:19:38to a greater degree than any other Canadian municipality
2:19:41keeps falling on its face by not taking care of the basics
2:19:45and building a transit system that people want to use,
2:19:48want to use.
2:19:51Now it seems like we're ready to finally remove transit
2:19:53from St. George's Square permanently.
2:19:55Am I wrong?
2:19:58I don't know.
2:19:59But I think if it was important,
2:20:01would have been mentioned in the report.
2:20:03And it wasn't.
2:20:05I hope Council has some intelligent questions for staff
2:20:08that might ensure that any future plans for Upper Wyndham
2:20:11and St. George's Square include transit and transit users.
2:20:15Thank you.
2:20:17Okay, thank you so much.
2:20:18Any follow up questions?
2:20:19Councillor Downer, please.
2:20:21Yeah, through you, Mr. Mayor, Mr. Donaldson.
2:20:23So is it a concern that because it's single lanes,
2:20:28it won't get down there fast enough
2:20:30or that there won't be stops in St. George's Square?
2:20:33Both.
2:20:35Okay.
2:20:37Thank you. Is there anything else?
2:20:39No, thank you very much, Adam.
2:20:41Thank you.
2:20:42Oh, sorry, Adam.
2:20:43Sorry, did Leigh Ann have your hand?
2:20:45I'm sorry, Councillor Caron,
2:20:46did you have your hand up or no?
2:20:48No, it was going to be a staff question.
2:20:50Thanks.
2:20:50Okay, no problem, Adam.
2:20:52Thank you.
2:20:52And while I go to you,
2:20:55well, first of all,
2:20:55would someone be willing to at least move the recommendations
2:20:58so that we can get that on the floor?
2:21:01Thank you, Councillor Allt and Gawler.
2:21:03And then while I go to you, Councillor Caron,
2:21:04for the first question to staff.
2:21:06Sure, through you, Mr. Mayor.
2:21:07So the delegation's brought up a significant point
2:21:11that buses will go through this intersection.
2:21:13That's a given.
2:21:16Without a lay-by, it could cause some traffic issues.
2:21:22Is a lay-by already?
2:21:25I mean, we saw the drawings, we've got the report.
2:21:28Is this something that can be incorporated
2:21:30into recommendation, I believe it's clause 1B?
2:21:36We've given direction that it be an offset intersection
2:21:39similar to existing conditions
2:21:41with operational improvements.
2:21:43We've specifically stated separated
2:21:45undirectional bike paths.
2:21:47Would you also like direction
2:21:49to incorporate transit lay-bys into the design?
2:21:54Or is that something that you had already anticipated
2:21:58in detailed design?
2:22:02Sure, we'll have staff respond to that.
2:22:05And just before you do,
2:22:06just so everyone knows that I didn't skip somebody,
2:22:09our next delegation was unavailable.
2:22:11Okay, so that's why Chuck wasn't on.
2:22:14And I went right to staff.
2:22:16So to staff our Councillor Caron's question.
2:22:19So through the matter, Councillor Caron,
2:22:21I'll start on behalf of transit
2:22:22and then may ask Ms. Holmes to jump in.
2:22:24So I don't wanna speak in specifics about the details
2:22:28because I'm not as familiar with that,
2:22:29but to reassure you that our transit staff
2:22:32have been well involved in this process throughout
2:22:34in terms of the design of the square
2:22:36and working with the transportation and engineering staff
2:22:39to make sure that we are doing what we need to do
2:22:42to maintain transit access through the square
2:22:45under this current design.
2:22:47So to the extent that I can give you the reassurance
2:22:49that our staff have worked well together on this design
2:22:51and that transit needs have been considered,
2:22:54I'll give you that reassurance
2:22:55and I'll look to see if Ms. Holmes wants to add anything.
2:22:58Sure, thank you.
2:22:59And through you, Mr. Mayor.
2:23:02And again, just to echo that we've been working collaboratively
2:23:05actually quite closely with transit
2:23:07over the last couple of years on this project.
2:23:10I know that we are not proposing parking in the areas
2:23:13where buses currently stop
2:23:15and we are maintaining those existing bus stops
2:23:19that we have right now.
2:23:20So a lot of this detail will come out
2:23:23as we go through detailed design.
2:23:25What you're looking at today is the concept,
2:23:26but as we go through detailed design,
2:23:28we'll certainly make sure that transit concerns are addressed.
2:23:34Thanks, Councillor Kerrani.
2:23:35You still have the floor if you need it.
2:23:36Yeah, I guess specifically,
2:23:42the recommendation specifically states
2:23:46separated unidirectional bike paths.
2:23:49So is there, given that that's such a specific ask,
2:23:56I wonder whether there's benefit to Council
2:24:00putting an amendment and I'm looking for direction here
2:24:04where we ensure that transit boarding and offloading
2:24:11are included in the design.
2:24:15Only because the bike paths are so specific
2:24:17in the recommendation and transit isn't.
2:24:22If you're telling me you don't need specifics
2:24:25in the recommendation to ensure that those
2:24:27are part of detailed design,
2:24:29then I'm gonna trust you on that
2:24:30and we will have the minutes from the meeting
2:24:34to fall back on if we need to.
2:24:35But if you do want direction, tell us now.
2:24:44Through you, Mr. Mayor, to Councillor Kerrani,
2:24:46we don't need specific directions,
2:24:47so we'll take the concerns that we have heard today
2:24:49and make sure that we're incorporating that
2:24:52in the detailed design.
2:24:54Councillor Downer.
2:24:56So I just wanna be clear,
2:24:58the design I'm looking at has transit labis in it.
2:25:04Yes, our staff are saying that.
2:25:07So we have transit labis in option two, right?
2:25:12But we're not going with option two, right?
2:25:14So we'll just know which one.
2:25:16Actually, they all have.
2:25:22Yeah, because the diagrams I'm looking at.
2:25:24Maybe we could ask our head engineer,
2:25:27Stacy, from downtown.
2:25:29Maybe they could come down just to inform us
2:25:33a little bit here.
2:25:34So I see labis and I see with,
2:25:36still with two lanes of traffic,
2:25:39and the lay by and the bike lanes.
2:25:44So the parking is taken out of these sections.
2:25:48Is that the way it is?
2:26:01So good evening, everyone.
2:26:02And through you, Mayor,
2:26:03I got through to Councillor Downer.
2:26:04So what we're seeing is the EA conceptual design level
2:26:07of information.
2:26:08Certainly we're existing bus lay by areas
2:26:11or stops or things like that exist now.
2:26:14They're shown, for example, and shown in concept.
2:26:17And as Ms. Holmes has said,
2:26:19the detailed design process will be very integrated
2:26:22with our transit team and our transit operations folks
2:26:25to make sure that all of the necessary things
2:26:26that they require will be embedded in the design.
2:26:29Okay, so even though this is a concept now,
2:26:32and you're going to get into detailed design,
2:26:33but this concept has transit labis in them.
2:26:37That's my understanding.
2:26:38It doesn't impede.
2:26:42I mean, there is still is parking definitely up
2:26:44and down Wyndham, but that would be the two lanes,
2:26:48but the bus will not, once it goes into the lay by, it's still,
2:26:53okay, that's fine.
2:26:55Yeah.
2:26:59I was simply going to say, Mr. Mayor, that that's correct.
2:27:04Okay.
2:27:05Is there any other questions at this time?
2:27:08Councillor Busuttil, please.
2:27:13Work?
2:27:14Yeah, it's coming through great.
2:27:15Thank you.
2:27:16I just had a question for staff,
2:27:19whether or not in consideration of the options
2:27:21and the design, not just consultation with transit,
2:27:26but does it improve the transit service delivery?
2:27:30Is that one of the key objectives of the design changes
2:27:35and modifications?
2:27:36Thank you.
2:27:42Through the mayor to Councillor Busuttil,
2:27:44certainly we look at everything through the lens
2:27:46of making sure that we are,
2:27:48we're possible improving transit,
2:27:50but at the very least making sure
2:27:52we're not impacting transit negatively.
2:27:55And so again, I don't wanna get too far into the details
2:27:58and make commitments without those,
2:28:01our transit planning staff here,
2:28:03but I again, can just reassure that transit staff
2:28:07have been integral to this planning.
2:28:09And I am confident in saying that this plan
2:28:12does not negatively impact transit
2:28:14and that the conversations between transit
2:28:16and engineering about a number of different ways
2:28:18to improve our transit system have been factored into this
2:28:22and all of the discussions that they have.
2:28:27Thank you.
2:28:30Thank you, Councillor Goller.
2:28:33Thank you, through your worship to staff.
2:28:36Looking at the report, I see the list of the different
2:28:40engagements that were done,
2:28:42but I'm hearing from the delegate today
2:28:45and also we received a letter from the transit
2:28:48action alliance of Guelph.
2:28:49Could I just hear from staff in terms of the involvement
2:28:52from the community?
2:28:53And then there's an advisory committee to transit
2:28:57where they involved and they provided input.
2:29:01Through the mayor to Councillor Goller.
2:29:02So just for clarification,
2:29:04the transit advisory committee is the council appointed
2:29:06committee and we do meet with them monthly
2:29:09and review a number of transit related matters.
2:29:13I don't want to speak specifically about
2:29:17if and when this was considered on their agenda
2:29:18simply because I don't have that information in front of me
2:29:20as to when it may have been.
2:29:22The transit, the tag letter that you're referring to,
2:29:27we were not contacted by TAG in advance
2:29:30and did not have discussions with them about their submission
2:29:33and we are comfortable that again,
2:29:36what our transit staff have been discussing
2:29:38with the transportation and engineering team
2:29:40has well addressed any concerns
2:29:42and so we don't share their concern.
2:29:45Okay, thank you and as a follow up to that,
2:29:47moving forward, where would be the next opportunity
2:29:52for the public to provide input
2:29:53as we go into the detailed design?
2:29:58So through the mayor, I'm simply gonna comment
2:29:59on the transit side of things,
2:30:00which is that we will continue
2:30:02to engage our transit advisory committee.
2:30:04That having been set our transit staff
2:30:06do reach out to TAG regularly and offer to meet,
2:30:09they just haven't taken us up on that offer.
2:30:12So on the transit side,
2:30:13we will continue to use our transit advisory committee
2:30:16as our lens or mechanism through which we consult on transit
2:30:20but that's a very narrow transit specific response.
2:30:22So I'll turn to Terri and Stacey to see if they can comment
2:30:25on the broader community engagement.
2:30:28Thank you DCO Clackbush and through the mayor,
2:30:31certainly there's a number of community touch points
2:30:33coming up, Councillor Goller,
2:30:34with respect to sort of the program overall
2:30:36in terms of downtown reconstruction
2:30:39as early as March of this year,
2:30:40we'll be talking to the community
2:30:41about the capital implementation plan.
2:30:43We'll be in front of council again in April
2:30:46with respect to streetscaping levels of service
2:30:48and those kinds of things through the workshop.
2:30:50So there's a number of checkpoints coming in
2:30:51and then as we get into the detailed designs
2:30:53for each given stretch of reconstruction in downtown,
2:30:56we will follow our standard process
2:30:59for any sort of reconstruction work that we do
2:31:01where we have public information centers,
2:31:03things of that nature where we can engage
2:31:04and answer community questions.
2:31:06Okay, thank you very much.
2:31:08And so that I understand that that point,
2:31:11so far we've only seen a cross section.
2:31:13When you come back to us in March, April,
2:31:16during the spring and summer,
2:31:18will we see the detailed layout of the whole street
2:31:20and will the public have an opportunity to comment
2:31:23on that before it is finalized?
2:31:27So through the mayor to Councillor Goller,
2:31:29so the March and April opportunities
2:31:32are more about streetscaping levels of service,
2:31:34capital implementation, how should the construction go?
2:31:37Those types of questions
2:31:38are what we'll be asking the community.
2:31:40With respect to detailed design,
2:31:41certainly we go out to the community,
2:31:43we don't go out at 100% design.
2:31:45So for designs like this,
2:31:46we may go at 60 or 90%, things like that,
2:31:48where we can hear from the community,
2:31:49make sure we understand the information
2:31:52that they might be able to offer
2:31:53so we can make any adjustments.
2:31:55Okay, thank you.
2:31:56And what is the timeline that we could expect
2:31:59to see that 60% design
2:32:02so we can actually see what the street might look like?
2:32:05So through the mayor to Councillor Goller,
2:32:06we are in the consultant procurement process right now.
2:32:09So the consultant award,
2:32:11I'm hoping will be within the next few weeks.
2:32:13And then it really depends on their schedule
2:32:15and what they provide to us,
2:32:16but it's possible that that could be later this year
2:32:19or if not in 2025.
2:32:20Okay, thank you.
2:32:21Thank you, Worship.
2:32:23Thank you.
2:32:23And then finally is Councillor Downer and then it'll work.
2:32:27Yeah, so just maybe a question or suggestion.
2:32:30So I sort of am seeing when we do their options,
2:32:34it talks about the key features pros and cons
2:32:37and talks about overall talks about pedestrians,
2:32:41the pros and cons for cyclists,
2:32:42the pros and cons for roadway and public realm.
2:32:45So maybe what I'm hearing without transit being mentioned,
2:32:50it's not mentioned.
2:32:51So when we come back in the future
2:32:56on the designs for the downtown
2:32:59and this could we sort of have transit included
2:33:01as sort of in those types of charts
2:33:03that talk about pros and cons just as for the pros,
2:33:06so that we have that information as well.
2:33:11So through the mayor,
2:33:12if I understand the question, Councillor Downer,
2:33:14really what we're doing for the environmental assessment
2:33:16process is where you look at sort of the feasibility study
2:33:18angle.
2:33:19So what are the options, what are the pros and cons?
2:33:21Once we move forward with an option
2:33:22and get into detailed design,
2:33:24we don't really come forward with the same type of analysis.
2:33:27So what I can simply say is,
2:33:30the options in front of council this evening,
2:33:34they're compliant with the quality transit network
2:33:35identified in our transportation master plan,
2:33:38our transit staff are well synced in as you've heard
2:33:41and we're gonna continue to work with them,
2:33:42which is our standard practice in all of our designs.
2:33:45Okay, so when we,
2:33:48when any time this is reported back though
2:33:50is what I'm suggesting is that transit is referenced as well.
2:33:54I understand that we've picking an option now
2:33:57and that's what we have in this environmental assessment,
2:34:00but when we come back with any kind of information on this,
2:34:04that that be sort of updated that way.
2:34:08Through the mayor, I can certainly take the feedback back.
2:34:10I'm just trying to think of one the appropriate point
2:34:13in process there would be and realistically,
2:34:16things like capital implementation plan
2:34:18is around construction sequencing.
2:34:19It's not around detailed design elements.
2:34:21So there's not necessarily with common
2:34:23with all of our construction projects,
2:34:24a council check-in with respect to detailed design, right?
2:34:29Those things are usually through multi-year budget approved,
2:34:31design construct and we proceed.
2:34:34So even on our streetscaping though,
2:34:36will it not include the transit elements
2:34:39in St. George's Square?
2:34:41So certainly from a street scaping perspective,
2:34:44we will go through that at the April workshop
2:34:46and report back in June with respect to sort of
2:34:50what staff's recommendation is with respect
2:34:52to street scaping levels so that we can then go
2:34:53and build the budget confirmation.
2:34:55I'm sorry, maybe I'm just misunderstanding,
2:34:57but I'm just with respect to detailed design,
2:34:59there's not really a return point to council.
2:35:02Yeah, okay.
2:35:03But sort of when that comes back, even for that,
2:35:05that will incorporate the designs.
2:35:07Yeah, okay.
2:35:12Okay, we'll go to council or work and then the CAO
2:35:15for wrap up comments.
2:35:19I'll go to you councillor, go ahead.
2:35:21Thank you, Mayor Guthrie, through you to staff.
2:35:22So I asked questions about transit at Community the Hole
2:35:25earlier this month about sort of to Mr. Donaldson's point,
2:35:31will a bus be caught behind a vehicle
2:35:34that's waiting to park or a delivery truck?
2:35:39So I'm wondering, are there ways to mitigate that potential?
2:35:44And because if I understand Q-Jump lanes properly,
2:35:47there wouldn't be a whole lot of potential
2:35:49for a technology like that.
2:35:51So I'm just wondering, what are some mitigating factors
2:35:55that might help ensure that the transit continues
2:35:58to run on time given the new design?
2:36:07Mr. Mayor, why don't I jump in a little bit here?
2:36:09Because I think I can actually be helpful to,
2:36:12you know, the last series of questions.
2:36:14You've got a massive, massive, massive
2:36:16downtown projects on our hands.
2:36:18We happen to be, we've got a delegate tonight
2:36:21that's asking about transit and that's important,
2:36:24but so is it all.
2:36:25So, you know, you've just mentioned delivery.
2:36:27So we've paid a lot of attention to,
2:36:29what does that mean for folks in the downtown
2:36:32that need those deliveries?
2:36:34And how can we accommodate that?
2:36:35But we also want people to park,
2:36:36but there's parking garages that aren't always full.
2:36:39So as always, the professional staff
2:36:41will take all of those into consideration.
2:36:43And I think the great opportunity,
2:36:45I mean, my gosh, I started here in 2015
2:36:47and this EA was underway.
2:36:49So there has been a ton of opportunities
2:36:52for people to come out and comment
2:36:54on the actual environmental assessment and the design work,
2:36:57but there will be a ton of opportunities
2:36:59as we update all the things that will happen in the downtown.
2:37:03And, you know, and especially as the downtown council
2:37:06would know, but all of you would know,
2:37:08that's when we'll actually then start to put things
2:37:10in front of the community with more detailed design,
2:37:13but expectation wise, it shouldn't be that offline
2:37:16of what you would have approved at committee
2:37:19the whole in this evening.
2:37:21So if it's one lane and then we're shown up with five,
2:37:23something drastic has gone on and we will accommodate transit,
2:37:27you know, can we accommodate all the things
2:37:30that might happen on any given day on Wyndham?
2:37:33No, but we may be able to accommodate,
2:37:36look, Wednesdays is the best day and there's a lane for that.
2:37:39And, you know, so that's the ongoing work
2:37:41that will take place to the broader issue
2:37:44of this transformational intergenerational project.
2:37:48And there'll be lots of updates there.
2:37:49And I think that's councillor downer,
2:37:51that might be where a lot of that information will be shared.
2:37:54There'll be open houses because you're going to have residents
2:37:57that will be concerned.
2:37:58Will there be construction in the evenings?
2:38:01I think that's equally as important to the discussion tonight,
2:38:03but we haven't got all those details worked out.
2:38:05Or from a merchant's perspective, the street will be closed.
2:38:09How will people get to me and how will my business survive?
2:38:12So we've got lots of work to do.
2:38:15The decisions got to get made
2:38:16and then you get to a lot of that detail.
2:38:18There is no way that transit is at the bottom of this list,
2:38:21but there's no way that deliveries are at the top either.
2:38:24So we've got that balancing act.
2:38:25And we've got to make sure that the engagement process
2:38:28that you've got us a protocol we have, we will include that.
2:38:32And I think there'll be lots of time for you to come out
2:38:34to those open houses as well in those sessions
2:38:37to work through all of this as we get closer to detail.
2:38:40So I hope you see it as tonight,
2:38:42that staff are uncertain whether we got it
2:38:44and it's going to be incorporated.
2:38:47And the EA happened to pick up on the subject line
2:38:49that's in their bi-directional bike lanes.
2:38:51That was important just because of this,
2:38:55is this an act of, I won't even try not to say it,
2:38:59traffic circle, and that was a debate for a long time too.
2:39:03So that's just general direction.
2:39:05I think we're all over this.
2:39:07And there'll be lots of opportunity
2:39:09for both the residential folks and our business folks
2:39:12in this community to continue to stay well informed
2:39:15of what we're up to.
2:39:17And we won't deviate that far away from this plan.
2:39:19I can't say that loud enough.
2:39:21We have got to get to action and stop talking.
2:39:23These EA's take way too long.
2:39:26Hopefully that's helpful in terms of those information,
2:39:29things will come along for the public
2:39:30to continue to be fully engaged.
2:39:37Thank you, DCO, CAO's, through you, Margarit,
2:39:40through staff.
2:39:41And I'm just wondering, so we're talking about transit
2:39:44because it has come up in the context of this EA,
2:39:46but we don't have like a transit commission
2:39:49or a councillor sit.
2:39:49So we get to talk about transit
2:39:51when a master plan comes or a route review comes,
2:39:56but will there be an opportunity to look at transit
2:39:59holistically because there are some changes planned
2:40:02for Guelph Central Station.
2:40:04There will be transit impacts.
2:40:06So I'm just wondering, what's the mechanism for that
2:40:08to come back?
2:40:09Is it an information report?
2:40:10Does it come back at a certain point?
2:40:11And really, I understand that it's a separate issue
2:40:14from Wyndham, but we're looking at Wyndham Street
2:40:18and not connecting it over to Cardin, right?
2:40:21So that's my, I'm just trying to understand,
2:40:22what's the right forum for us to have that information?
2:40:27Through you, Mr. Mayor, a couple of,
2:40:29let me answer that a couple of ways.
2:40:30A, I think every time that you see Ms. Laughlin at the table,
2:40:33you'll understand that the entire downtown has been reviewed.
2:40:36And she's not letting any of us not look at the downtown
2:40:39in an isolated sliver.
2:40:41The other part of this is we are having
2:40:43current discussions with people, folks,
2:40:45agencies like Metrolinx.
2:40:47What's your focus in the station?
2:40:50And is there a reason that we would have a station
2:40:52and you have a station and why is yours not open?
2:40:54And doesn't your clientele, our clientele,
2:40:56want to actually have some place to shelter?
2:40:59And there's lots of back and forth behind the scenes on that,
2:41:02not ready for primetime yet, although I just said that out loud.
2:41:05So I think there's lots of places
2:41:07that we will likely come back to you to just say so.
2:41:11Here's that subset, the master plan on transit,
2:41:14that's not subservient to, but sits in the downtown projects
2:41:20so that we can't let, with all due respect,
2:41:21we can't let Mr. Gamanoff and doing all kinds of crazy things
2:41:24on infrastructure and not contemplate
2:41:26what that means above ground.
2:41:28And I know he doesn't not contemplate that.
2:41:30But so I think we will have something separate for that
2:41:34because there might be a change in maybe how we do some service
2:41:37in the downtown.
2:41:38And then there's other things that make a change.
2:41:425,000 students from Conestoga make a change.
2:41:45And what does that change look like?
2:41:47And does this change accommodate it
2:41:49so that we can move people in and out of the downtown on transit?
2:41:52So there likely will be, as we get closer to some details
2:41:56on some of these other big capital expenditures,
2:41:59an opportunity to put that in front of you to say,
2:42:01so this is an opportunity for some change
2:42:05that sits within the big broad-based plan,
2:42:09but to transit specific.
2:42:10And I went to the central station component of it.
2:42:13But that's our central station too.
2:42:16And is there an opportunity for something there
2:42:18that's maybe more excited than what takes place today?
2:42:21So hopefully that answers it as well.
2:42:23We've got to bring this stuff to you
2:42:24so that you can A, see action and then B,
2:42:26see how we're implementing it.
2:42:28And if we have to make some changes,
2:42:29we should adjust whether it's segregated bike lines everywhere.
2:42:35My comment to staff is let's move those things through.
2:42:38But half a loaf is better than no loaf.
2:42:39Like we have got to stop thinking and planning
2:42:42and never doing, and this is the doing part now.
2:42:45So we will bring the other changes back to you,
2:42:47Councillor O'Rourke, so that you as the Board of Governors
2:42:50are well in tune with everything.
2:42:54Thank you.
2:42:55Okay, so before I call the vote,
2:42:58I got to yes or no question
2:43:00to wrap up all the questions that we've had.
2:43:02You've heard us.
2:43:03We're looking for some kind of a touch point
2:43:06that specifically addresses any transit concerns
2:43:10that might pop up as we move forward in detail design
2:43:13and other reports, opportunities, workshops, open houses.
2:43:18We're going to hear about it.
2:43:19Through you, Mr. Yer.
2:43:20Yes. Thank you.
2:43:22That's all we need to hear. Thank you.
2:43:24Okay, I will look to call the vote then.
2:43:27Is anyone against?
2:43:30Nobody, that's unanimous.
2:43:32Thank you very much.
2:43:33And thank you to staff.
Automatic transcription is imperfect. Treat quotes as a guide and check the recording before relying on exact wording.
The motion, the vote and the debate come from the City of Guelph’s published record, reproduced rather than interpreted. The document summaries above are the exception: those words were written for this site.