Skip to main content
Jon Christensen
Guelph Council Record

City Council · October 28, 2025 · Item 9.4

On behalf of the City of Guelph, the Deputy CAO of Infrastructure, Development and Environment, subject to the satisfaction of the City Solicitor and City Treasurer, be directed to enter into a lease for the Baker Library…

Main motion under the agenda item Baker Library Facility Lease Approval - 2025-441, 2025-514

Carried (13 to 0)

13 in favour, 0 against — unanimous

This was one of 3 motions on the same item

In the order council took them. A vote makes sense next to the ones around it.

  1. 1/3Main motionOn behalf of the City of Guelph, the Deputy CAO of Infrastructure, Development and Environment, subject to the satisfaction of the City Solicitor and City Treasurer, be directed to enter into a lease for the Baker Library…Differs here: …Baker Library facility for a thirty year term that has two, five-year renewal terms.no recorded vote
  2. 2/3Main motionOn behalf of the City of Guelph, the Deputy CAO of Infrastructure, Development and Environment, subject to the satisfaction of the City Solicitor and City Treasurer, be directed to enter into a lease for the Baker Library…Differs here: …Baker Library facility for a forty year term that has one ten-year renewal term.Word for word the same as another motion on this item.Carried (13 to 0)
  3. 3/3Main motionOn behalf of the City of Guelph, the Deputy CAO of Infrastructure, Development and Environment, subject to the satisfaction of the City Solicitor and City Treasurer, be directed to enter into a lease for the Baker Library…you are hereDiffers here: …Baker Library facility for a forty year term that has one ten-year renewal term.Word for word the same as another motion on this item.Carried (13 to 0)

What was voted on

The motion in its exact words, as recorded in the minutes.

That on behalf of the City of Guelph, the Deputy CAO of Infrastructure, Development and Environment, subject to the satisfaction of the City Solicitor and City Treasurer, be directed to enter into a lease for the Baker Library facility for a forty year term that has one ten-year renewal term.

Moved by Councillor Goller, seconded by Councillor Klassen.

How the room voted

In favour (13)

  • Allt
  • Billings
  • Busuttil
  • Caron
  • Caton
  • Chew
  • Downer
  • Gibson
  • Goller
  • Guthrie
  • Hauser
  • Klassen
  • Richardson

What council was given

The staff reports and correspondence attached to this item. The summaries are written automatically, so you can tell what a document is without opening a ninety-page PDF.

A summary is this site’s description of a document, not the City’s. Open the document before relying on one.

What was said

779 words from the meeting recording, transcribed automatically. Times are from the start of the recording.

Read the debate(click to open)

2:12:25I think we have a motion to move the motion.

2:12:28That your motion is pretty quick.

2:12:31On the library. Am I right? I believe so.

2:12:33You're working with me. Yeah. Okay.

2:12:36Yeah.

2:12:37Good question on it. Okay. I'm going to, I'm going to say let's do it.

2:12:41Perfect. Okay. So, but just being mindful of time.

2:12:44Just to get this one out of the way. Go ahead.

2:12:46Your worship. I would like to move a motion.

2:12:50Okay.

2:12:51Thank you.

2:12:52Thank you.

2:12:53Okay.

2:12:54So, yeah.

2:12:55Effectively, the staff recommendation originally was for a 30 year

2:12:58lease with two, five year renewals after conversations between staff

2:13:02and library staff.

2:13:04Staff added a memo to this item saying that they were okay with a

2:13:0940 year lease with one 10 year renewal term.

2:13:12And that is the only change here.

2:13:14Okay. So, I'm just going to move the motion.

2:13:17I think we'll be seconding this. Okay. So just to be,

2:13:20just to confirm,

2:13:21are you moving what's on here with an amendment for the 40 years?

2:13:26Or are you just moving it with the 40 years?

2:13:29I would prefer if you put the original motion down and seconded by

2:13:33Councillor Klassen. Yes.

2:13:35And then you moved an, an amendment to change the 30 years to the 40.

2:13:40That's.

2:13:41Okay. So we're just talking about the amendment only right now.

2:13:44I got one question from Councillor Allt.

2:13:46Okay. Just turn up here.

2:13:47Thank you, Mayor Guthrie.

2:13:48It's a question through you to staff in the memo that came to us on this,

2:13:54the last two paragraphs, I think are fairly pertinent.

2:13:57City is Landlord is responsible for major capital repairs and

2:14:01replacement.

2:14:02And then it goes on in a typical commercial lease for a long duration.

2:14:06It's common for Landlord to insist on a redevelopment clause.

2:14:10And I'm wondering what the significance of this is given that we are extending

2:14:15the lease and that this is a public building, not a typical commercial lease.

2:14:21Through the mayor to Councillor Allt.

2:14:28I may start and may see if our general manager of facilities and energy can come

2:14:32down and speak to you on that.

2:14:34I do know, I think sort of fundamentally we're comfortable with the proposed

2:14:38amendment in terms of the timing that we've got here,

2:14:41but Ian can speak a little bit more here to your specific question.

2:14:44Through the chair to Councillor Allt.

2:14:50That clause is about if we were to extend, so the memo speaks to the typical

2:14:56period of investment is that 30 to 50 year window.

2:15:00We don't know exactly when that will be.

2:15:02It's a bit of a gray area, 40 years in the future.

2:15:05And that those two paragraphs really speak to if we were to extend out to like

2:15:10a 60 year or a 70 year lease, then we'd be wanting to be looking at what

2:15:13happens in that period of investment because we're aligned to that period of

2:15:17investment that we've covered off the concern within those paragraphs.

2:15:22Thank you very much.

2:15:24I appreciate the answer.

2:15:25So what I've now learned is that a 40 year lease is not a long lease.

2:15:29It's a medium term lease.

2:15:32Is that correct?

2:15:36Through Councillor Allt, it all depends on your reference period,

2:15:39but for this staff can support the request from Councillor Goller.

2:15:45Thank you very much.

2:15:47All right. Thank you.

2:15:48Any other questions on this amendment only?

2:15:50No. Okay.

2:15:52Well, I'll just very quick comment for me.

2:15:54I'm more way more comfortable today than I am from the committee of the whole.

2:15:58And sometimes, by the way, I'm looking in the mirror when I say this,

2:16:01sometimes that breath that you take just a pause over 20 days or so or whatever

2:16:06is worthwhile sometimes.

2:16:08So I think I just want to recognize you, Councillor Goller,

2:16:11for bringing it forward fair enough.

2:16:12But I also want to recognize staff for kind of being able to pull together the

2:16:15information that makes me, and I think many members of council feel a lot more

2:16:19comfortable in looking to support this than what was originally kind of proposed

2:16:22at the beginning, but at least kickstarted the conversation.

2:16:24So that's fair, right?

2:16:26Okay. So I'm going to call the vote on the amendment.

2:16:28Does anyone against the amendment?

2:16:29Nobody.

2:16:31Okay.

2:16:32I'm going to go back to the main motion now as amended.

2:16:34I'm going to call the vote.

2:16:35Is anyone against the main motion as amended now?

2:16:38Nope.

2:16:39We're done.

2:16:40Thank you very much.

2:16:42It's a unanimous vote, by the way, everybody.

2:16:45Okay. Let me move on.

2:16:48We have only one item on the consent agenda for council,

Automatic transcription is imperfect. Treat quotes as a guide and check the recording before relying on exact wording.

Check this against the City’s official minutes

The motion, the vote and the debate come from the City of Guelph’s published record, reproduced rather than interpreted. The document summaries above are the exception: those words were written for this site.

See the rest of this meeting