City Council · October 24, 2023 · Item 6.4
Culture Plan 2030 be approved. That costs associated with the implementation of Culture Plan 2030 be referred to the 2024-2027 multi-year budget process. That staff be…
Deferral under the agenda item Culture Plan 2030 Staff Report - 2023-358
Carried (13 to 0)
13 in favour, 0 against — unanimous
This was one of 3 motions on the same item
In the order council took them. A vote makes sense next to the ones around it.
- 1/3DeferralCulture Plan 2030 be approved. That costs associated with the implementation of Culture Plan 2030 be referred to the 2024-2027 multi-year budget process.no recorded vote
- 2/3Main motionStaff to consider an additional recommendation for inclusion in the Culture Plan regarding City owned cultural…Carried (13 to 0)
- 3/3DeferralCulture Plan 2030 be approved. That costs associated with the implementation of Culture Plan 2030 be referred to the 2024-2027 multi-year budget process. That staff be…you are hereCarried (13 to 0)
What was voted on
The motion in its exact words, as recorded in the minutes.
That Culture Plan 2030 be approved. That costs associated with the implementation of Culture Plan 2030 be referred to the 2024-2027 multi-year budget process. That staff be directed to consider an additional recommendation for inclusion in the Culture Plan regarding City owned cultural, archival or heritage artifacts that considers incorporating such artifacts into public display for adaptive reuse and place making, in alignment with the existing public art policy and museum collections policies and report back to Council no later than Q2 2025.
Moved by Councillor Busuttil, seconded by Councillor Caton.
How the room voted
In favour (13)
- Allt
- Billings
- Busuttil
- Caron
- Caton
- Chew
- Downer
- Gibson
- Goller
- Guthrie
- Klassen
- O'Rourke
- Richardson
What council was given
The staff reports and correspondence attached to this item. The summaries are written automatically, so you can tell what a document is without opening a ninety-page PDF.
- Culture Plan 2030 Staff Report - 2023-358.pdf
Council is asked to approve Culture Plan 2030, a long-term strategy for arts, heritage and creative industry in Guelph, and to send its costs to the 2024-2027 multi-year budget process. The plan responds to problems the report identifies for local artists, including a shortage of affordable studio, rehearsal, exhibition and performance space, limited opportunity for equity-deserving residents, and low incomes against rising living costs.
- Attachment-1 Culture Plan 2030.pdf
- Attachment-2 Culture Plan 2030 Community Engagement and Research Report.pdf
- Attachment-3 Culture Plan 2023 Staff Presentation.pdf
A summary is this site’s description of a document, not the City’s. Open the document before relying on one.
What was said
1,078 words from the meeting recording, transcribed automatically. Times are from the start of the recording.
Read the debate(click to open)
2:33:29who asked for the cultural plan 2030 staff report
2:33:35to be pulled, would you mind moving the two recommendations
2:33:39to put the main motion on the floor?
2:33:40Yes, who wants to second that one for me, the cultural plan?
2:33:44How about someone on screen here
2:33:46just to kind of spread the love?
2:33:48Councillor Caton will second that.
2:33:50Thank you, and I will turn it over to you.
2:33:54Councillor Busuttil, go ahead.
2:33:55Thank you.
2:33:56I first want to thank the staff for answering my questions
2:34:00and providing all sorts of context and background documents.
2:34:03And just to refresh Council's memory,
2:34:06I raised this when we were talking about the cultural plan
2:34:09specifically around the Mitchell Farm
2:34:11as residents in Ward 4 were asking about this
2:34:14and culture in Ward 4, didn't see it in the plan.
2:34:18And so I wanted to work with staff
2:34:20to try to capture some historical things
2:34:25that had meaning in a neighborhood
2:34:28that would be part of our culture.
2:34:30So before I do that though,
2:34:32I did have one question for staff,
2:34:34which was one of the concerns that was raised
2:34:36by the community around a concern
2:34:39that the Mitchell Wood Farmhouse Stone
2:34:43or the Cornerstone specifically
2:34:46have been lost somewhere in the city.
2:34:49If you can speak to that,
2:34:50and I know as I was working on this,
2:34:52I also received a text message as an email
2:34:55as people saying, well, what about the old Niska Bridge
2:34:57and what about this?
2:34:59I don't have that knowledge, that corporate
2:35:02and that historical knowledge.
2:35:03And so if staff could respond.
2:35:09So through the mayor to council and to Councillor Busuttil.
2:35:12So yes, and I'll speak a little bit
2:35:14on behalf of DCO homes as well.
2:35:16So she and I, irrespective of what may occur tonight,
2:35:20have already undertaken a process
2:35:22to make sure that we have a really thorough inventory
2:35:24of all of the city's civic archival
2:35:28or heritage assets, artifacts.
2:35:31Well, we have a very, very good system of storing.
2:35:34It is split across a number of different departments.
2:35:37And we want to have one consolidated inventory.
2:35:39We're going to work with staff, our heritage planning staff,
2:35:42our museum staff, so that we have that good inventory
2:35:45of all of those civic artifacts or archival materials
2:35:49that we have retained over the years,
2:35:51as well as make sure that we have a documented policy
2:35:55on where they can be utilized.
2:35:57And so I don't want to leave anyone with the impression
2:35:59that we don't have a good storage system or a good policy.
2:36:02It's just that we want to make sure
2:36:03that it's documented between our two service areas
2:36:05and that it's one coordinated approach.
2:36:07Specific to the Mitchell farmhouse, yes,
2:36:09I can confirm and reassure that per the agreements
2:36:14that were made at the time when that farmhouse was taken down,
2:36:19that the materials have been retained
2:36:21in a safe and secure location so that they can be utilized
2:36:24at a later date.
2:36:25For example, the production of a caron,
2:36:27I know, is something that had been agreed to,
2:36:29and that is still something that we are planning to do.
2:36:31And so without disclosing specific locations,
2:36:34I can reassure that those materials
2:36:36from the Mitchell farmhouse,
2:36:37as for some of the others that have been referenced,
2:36:40have all been retained.
2:36:41And Ms. Holmes and I have made sure ourselves
2:36:44that we are aware of all of those locations,
2:36:47but through the work that we're gonna do operationally,
2:36:50it will be about consolidating that
2:36:52into one tracked inventory so that we have a good record
2:36:55of everything that we have retained
2:36:57and what it either was intended to be used for
2:37:00or could be considered to be used for in the future.
2:37:03Thank you very much.
2:37:05And if the clerks can put up,
2:37:07I prepared a motion with that Councillor Downer
2:37:10and with the staff support and circulation for consideration.
2:37:16And so one of the questions that I had was why Q2 2025
2:37:21is that we would know the staff,
2:37:23planning staff and heritage staff are really quite busy
2:37:26trying to meet the deadlines.
2:37:28And so 2025 to bring us back a policy
2:37:30was their suggestion of a reasonable timeframe.
2:37:34And so I'd like to place that motion
2:37:36and I believe Councillor Downer has agreed to second it.
2:37:42Sorry, I have to read it on my phone.
2:37:44That staff.
2:37:44I'm sorry.
2:37:45Yeah, I can't see it here.
2:37:47Oh.
2:37:47That staff be directed to consider
2:37:49an additional recommendation for inclusion
2:37:52in the culture plan regarding city-owned cultural,
2:37:55archival or heritage artifacts
2:37:58that considers incorporating such artifacts
2:38:01into public display for adaptive reuse and placemaking
2:38:05in alignment with the existing public art policy,
2:38:09a museum collections policies
2:38:11and report back to council no later than Q2 2025.
2:38:17Okay.
2:38:18Does anyone want to speak to this at all?
2:38:21If not, it looks seem straightforward.
2:38:23Okay, Councillor Caron can speak to this.
2:38:26And then Downer can, as the seconder can speak
2:38:30before I call the vote.
2:38:31Go ahead.
2:38:32Okay, I thought I was raising my hand to second it,
2:38:35but I will be supporting the motion,
2:38:38although I wish it was sooner and I wish it was stronger.
2:38:43The definition of public art, the definition of culture,
2:38:46the definition of placemaking are all embedded
2:38:50in our current policies,
2:38:52are all embedded in our strategic objectives.
2:38:55And I think that we have a really big policy gap here
2:39:00that needs to be closed,
2:39:01that brings all of those things together,
2:39:04and the sooner the better, so happy to support.
2:39:07Thank you.
2:39:08And then Downer as the seconder.
2:39:10Just sort of did all to that,
2:39:11but I just wanted to point out too,
2:39:13that we didn't bring the motion around during the inventory
2:39:16because that's operational and deputy CEO Clark Bush
2:39:20and Holmes were both in the process
2:39:23of getting that underway now.
2:39:25So of doing an inventory of all of what we have in storage.
2:39:30In consultation with Heritage Guelph and the museum,
2:39:35or Heritage Guelph staff, I should say at the museum staff.
2:39:39Okay, great, thank you.
2:39:41All right, I'll call the vote on this particular motion then.
2:39:44Is anyone against that one?
2:39:47Seeing nobody, that's unanimous.
2:39:49Thank you, counselor.
2:39:50And then we're now back to the main motion then.
2:39:53Is there anything further on that?
2:39:55No, feeling good everybody?
2:39:58I'm gonna call the vote then.
2:39:59Anyone against the main motion?
2:40:03Again, that's unanimous in support.
2:40:05Thank you.
Automatic transcription is imperfect. Treat quotes as a guide and check the recording before relying on exact wording.
The motion, the vote and the debate come from the City of Guelph’s published record, reproduced rather than interpreted. The document summaries above are the exception: those words were written for this site.