Skip to main content
Jon Christensen
Guelph Council Record

Special Council Meeting · October 17, 2023 · Item 2.

Now hold a meeting that is closed to the public…

Main motion under the agenda item Authority to move into closed meeting

Carried (11 to 0)

11 in favour, 0 against — unanimous

What was voted on

The motion in its exact words, as recorded in the minutes.

That the Council of the City of Guelph now hold a meeting that is closed to the public, pursuant to the Municipal Act section 239(2) (f) of the Municipal Act relating to advice that is subject to solicitor-client privilege, including communications necessary for that purpose.

Moved by Councillor Klassen, seconded by Councillor O'Rourke.

How the room voted

In favour (11)

  • Allt
  • Busuttil
  • Caron
  • Caton
  • Chew
  • Downer
  • Gibson
  • Goller
  • Guthrie
  • Klassen
  • O'Rourke

What was said

4,632 words from the meeting recording, transcribed automatically. Times are from the start of the recording.

Read the debate(click to open)

1:41:50of different types of housing.

1:41:52And I think the biggest component of that

1:41:53is centering people's needs

1:41:55and what's going to work best for them.

1:41:57I didn't emphasize that enough in my delegation,

1:42:00but it's also crucial that we are centering the voices

1:42:02of folks who are experiencing these issues

1:42:04across the continuum.

1:42:06And I know as counselors, you and Mayor,

1:42:08do a really great job staff as well

1:42:10of listening to those concerns directly from community members.

1:42:13And I would encourage you to continue doing so

1:42:14to hear what's going to work best for people.

1:42:18Thank you.

1:42:19And just to let you know,

1:42:20I'm going to telegraph to staff.

1:42:21I'm going to ask them the same question.

1:42:23I think this one's really important type matters a lot.

1:42:26Thank you.

1:42:29Councillor work is next.

1:42:35Thank you, Margot three through you to miss McPherson.

1:42:39Can you help me understand how the concept

1:42:43or the principle of housing as a human right?

1:42:48What's the expectation on the municipality

1:42:50when you adopt housing as a human right?

1:42:52What's the expectation on the municipality

1:42:54to meet all of those things that it means?

1:42:56And I'm thinking especially in light of the province

1:42:59removing rent controls on anything built or occupied

1:43:02after 2018, the municipality can never fill that gap

1:43:06that's been created, right?

1:43:08So what's the, what is the expectation when we say,

1:43:10yeah, we are going to adopt housing

1:43:12as a human right principle.

1:43:17And so what is the community's understanding of that?

1:43:20Yeah, thank you for that question.

1:43:22And I will highlight,

1:43:23I know the collective results report

1:43:25did mention some great work happening across the country.

1:43:28Shift cities is one that you can look to

1:43:30for resourcing around that.

1:43:32But I think I'll just first start by saying,

1:43:34in many senses, you are already implementing a commitment

1:43:37to a right to housing.

1:43:39City staff have been supporting that in multiple capacities.

1:43:42It was referenced earlier.

1:43:43But when I think about committing to that as an approach,

1:43:47to me, what that is ensuring is that you're applying

1:43:50that as a lens to your decision-making.

1:43:52It's a commitment to really prioritize the rights

1:43:56and dignity of people in this community

1:43:57and have that inform when you're making decisions.

1:44:00It doesn't change what you're responsible for

1:44:03or what's available to you as a mechanism or lever,

1:44:06but rather it ensures that when you are navigating

1:44:08decision-making processes,

1:44:09you have a framework to support you in making decisions.

1:44:13There's no, although this is legislated nationally

1:44:17and internationally, I think it's important to recognize

1:44:20that the federal government has made that commitment

1:44:22and they're still working on realizing what that looks like.

1:44:26They haven't, the national housing strategy

1:44:28have recognized in some areas it's been very impactful

1:44:30in other areas, there's opportunities to improve that.

1:44:32So I think it's also a commitment

1:44:34to kind of continuous improvement

1:44:35and being able to also realize what that looks like

1:44:38in a municipal context.

1:44:39There are some other municipalities

1:44:40you can look to for that, but to me,

1:44:43it's really about ensuring that you're thinking

1:44:44about those factors when you're making decisions

1:44:47that you're already faced with.

1:44:48Great, thanks.

1:44:49And just a second question through you, Marigathe.

1:44:52So we've had this conversation before.

1:44:54We tend to be very, very hyper-focused

1:44:56on the folks who are currently homeless.

1:44:59And we're sort of, we're a little bit glib

1:45:04when we're talking about, well,

1:45:05I know the municipalities got to fill these gaps.

1:45:08I'm concerned about folks who are one paycheck away

1:45:11from not making their rent.

1:45:12I'm concerned about folks for whom

1:45:14a significant property tax increase will, you know,

1:45:17make their, either their rental unit unaffordable

1:45:19because it'll be passed along

1:45:21or their property tax payments unaffordable.

1:45:24So I'm often thinking about all those folks

1:45:26who are just not homeless yet,

1:45:28but they are waiting for subsidized housing

1:45:32or they are making it, but just barely.

1:45:35Can you help me understand?

1:45:38I'm gonna ask you to do my job for me.

1:45:41Can you help me understand the precarity of that

1:45:44and what the, you know, in economics called elasticity?

1:45:48What is the capacity in the community to absorb

1:45:52the property tax increases that,

1:45:54so 2% that the county came to present with us?

1:45:58Potentially additional asks, right?

1:46:01How do you think counselors should approach that

1:46:04rather than have you make the decision for us?

1:46:06How do you think we need to be thinking about that

1:46:08in the upcoming budget?

1:46:10Because we want to say yes to everybody

1:46:11who comes to the podium, right?

1:46:13We want this awesome community.

1:46:15And at the end of the day, it is the taxpayer,

1:46:17the worst, you know, the municipal level,

1:46:20the worst possible level to make a transfer of wealth,

1:46:24which is what this is.

1:46:25So what lens do you want us to bring to this

1:46:27when we look at the budget next week?

1:46:30Thank you for that big question.

1:46:32And obviously I'm best positioned to speak

1:46:34to the experiences of people

1:46:35living with low incomes in particular.

1:46:38However, I know people who previously were middle income

1:46:41and comfortable are facing increasing pressures

1:46:43in our community.

1:46:44And I've heard from people in that situation,

1:46:47living pay tech to paycheck.

1:46:49And with housing costs and other pressures,

1:46:51it is pushing people where we're seeing an increasing divide

1:46:55between lower and upper income experiences.

1:46:59So I appreciate the fact that council considers that seriously

1:47:02when you're looking at budgetary constraints and pressures.

1:47:05I think when considering the importance,

1:47:08one of the things I say like a broken record is,

1:47:11it is critical that we need emergency needs.

1:47:14And we need to have the same sense of urgency

1:47:17for root cause solutions.

1:47:18I don't want to under appreciate the significance

1:47:22of the asks and pressures that are coming before you today.

1:47:25I think it's important to consider the balance

1:47:28to be considering what you are positioned to do

1:47:31in relationship to other levels of government

1:47:33and the context you're operating within.

1:47:34It does put you in unique pressures,

1:47:37which means considering those different factors.

1:47:40But I would say a balance considering

1:47:42where you can have the greatest impact.

1:47:44Staff are amazing at being able to draw attention

1:47:47to those pieces.

1:47:48But obviously it's no surprise to you that I would always say

1:47:51it's important to prioritize the greatest steps of need.

1:47:54We know that when we prioritize the greatest steps of need

1:47:56from both an immediate needs

1:47:58and a root cause solution oriented approach,

1:48:02that we not only have a beneficial impact

1:48:05to points said earlier, save lives.

1:48:07We are also having a broader impact

1:48:09for our broader community.

1:48:11When we lift people up who are facing

1:48:12some of the greatest marginalizations and pressures,

1:48:15it has a positive impact, not just on their wellbeing,

1:48:17but our community wellbeing overall

1:48:19or economic wellbeing and on our ability

1:48:22to be able to support one another.

1:48:24So I would just encourage you to consider those factors.

1:48:28Sorry for not a more clear direction,

1:48:30but those would be pieces that I would continue to advocate

1:48:32for in your decision-making process.

1:48:34I appreciate that, thanks.

1:48:36Councillor Pusatil and Councillor Chew.

1:48:39Thank you very much for the presentation, Dominica.

1:48:42And thank you also for articulating those levers.

1:48:45It's not only about providing housing

1:48:48and those other things, but I wanna,

1:48:50it's about the income for me.

1:48:51It's about adequate income.

1:48:53Can you talk a little bit about the advocacy

1:48:55that you've done collectively or provincially

1:48:57or nationally around the social safety net?

1:49:00And I'm not speaking about charity.

1:49:02I'm talking about OW and ODSP and so on

1:49:05to support the human right to an adequate standard of living

1:49:10because these are the two pieces in here.

1:49:14Can you speak a little bit to that?

1:49:16Yeah, thank you for that question.

1:49:18As many of you know, the poverty task force

1:49:20is a collaborative in our community

1:49:22that brings together lived experts, decision makers,

1:49:25community groups and agencies under a shared commitment

1:49:28to take action and advocate for system and policy change

1:49:31to address the root causes of poverty.

1:49:33We have extensive advocacy efforts that we undertake

1:49:37towards all different levels of government.

1:49:40But I will say that disproportionately,

1:49:43a lot of our focus around income issues

1:49:45has been on the provincial government in particular.

1:49:47We're part of a number of provincial networks.

1:49:50We work really closely with both provincial

1:49:52and national organizations advocating on these issues.

1:49:57So, and then we use that by bringing forward the voices

1:50:01of people experiencing these issues in our community

1:50:03to amplify calls for action on that level.

1:50:06I will say, as I know council has faced in some capacities,

1:50:10advocacy has needed to look different than it has in the past.

1:50:14There's been around opportunities for consultation,

1:50:17opportunities to be able to engage in those conversations.

1:50:20On social assistance in particular,

1:50:22we're fortunate to have really strong relationships

1:50:24with the County of Wellington and employment agencies locally

1:50:28and have been following some of the modernization efforts

1:50:30that have been underway and have been really amplifying

1:50:33that modernization improvements to support life stabilization

1:50:37won't be meaningful or impactful

1:50:39in the absence of increased rates or meaningfully investing

1:50:43in the supports that people need

1:50:45on both the health and housing standpoint.

1:50:48So, on that standpoint, any opportunities we have

1:50:50to advance advocacy on those fronts

1:50:52at different levels of government, we do.

1:50:55We assign on to a number of different provincial

1:50:57and national campaigns in that regard

1:50:59and amplify it at a local level.

1:51:01And any opportunities to meet with elected officials,

1:51:04we welcome and we are here to try and support you

1:51:07in any resourcing or support you need

1:51:09to also be amplifying those calls.

1:51:12Thank you.

1:51:14And Chu, please.

1:51:16Thank you, through you, Mr. Mayor.

1:51:18Thank you for your delegation.

1:51:20I'm learning a lot about your group

1:51:24and I'm very impressed with the work that you guys have done

1:51:27with some of the current initiatives,

1:51:29including how you guys are tackling food security.

1:51:33I think you guys are in a very unique position

1:51:36because you guys are a coalition of local partners.

1:51:39I'm just curious to see how you guys go

1:51:42about information sharing and knowledge transfer

1:51:45with external partners that aren't within the city

1:51:49and county because I think they're a lot of excellent,

1:51:53they're a lot of excellent best practices

1:51:56that we can maybe use and apply.

1:51:58So I'm just curious, like how do you guys go

1:52:00about that process of disseminating information

1:52:03and bring that in when you guys meet as a group?

1:52:07Yeah, thank you for that question.

1:52:08Hopefully I understood it accurately.

1:52:11You can correct me if I didn't.

1:52:11So from a knowledge transfer, knowledge sharing component,

1:52:15we create a number of different resources.

1:52:16We recognize that people need to be engaged

1:52:18in different ways and we try to reflect that in our strategy

1:52:21and I often say we've got a lot of amazing

1:52:23and kind contributions to our work.

1:52:25We are a mighty team of two, staff in particular.

1:52:29So we really do leverage our networks, our connections,

1:52:32our broader partnerships to amplify those messages

1:52:34beyond the doors we're able to access or get through

1:52:38and we try to provide that support.

1:52:41On the flip side, one of our commitments

1:52:43is to be evidence informed.

1:52:45And that's evidence informed both from a standpoint

1:52:47of what we're hearing from folks experiencing the issues,

1:52:49but also looking to more formal research

1:52:52or best practices in other communities

1:52:54so that we can learn from that, help amplify those examples.

1:52:57The London work was just referenced earlier.

1:52:59It's a great example of kind of a collaborative approach

1:53:01to health and housing planning.

1:53:03So that's also something that we do

1:53:05and we're able to leverage a lot of that

1:53:07through broader networks at the provincial

1:53:09and federal level.

1:53:11Thank you and one quick follow up for me.

1:53:13You mentioned the London model

1:53:15as did our colleague from the chamber did.

1:53:18I was just wondering, I know your focus is really on,

1:53:22bring awareness towards rent, care to income,

1:53:25but I do see a lot of opportunity,

1:53:26especially with the groundswalling of conversation

1:53:29around housing throughout the province

1:53:31that we bring forward more formal education

1:53:36through our various meetings and discussions

1:53:39with different interest groups and development partners.

1:53:44I was wondering if there is appetite to even look

1:53:48at advocacy towards the market-based,

1:53:52I guess, affordable market-based component

1:53:58in our continuum.

1:54:00There's, I think, a lot of opportunities for education,

1:54:03for particularly small developers and local home owners

1:54:06on how they can individually take responsibility

1:54:09for looking at ways to retrofit their current footprint

1:54:16into something that could be attainable for folks

1:54:18on the left hand of the continuum.

1:54:20So I was wondering if there's appetite

1:54:22and if there's even opportunity that you see

1:54:25to collaborate with our folks at the chamber.

1:54:30Yeah, so I will say that I was fortunate,

1:54:32thanks to Shakiva and the chamber for their work

1:54:35to have an opportunity to meet with partners,

1:54:38especially for-profit developers,

1:54:40and had the opportunity to express to you what I did today,

1:54:43that I don't see that their best position

1:54:45to create the deeply affordable housing that we need,

1:54:47but there's huge opportunities for us to be partnering

1:54:50and to be leveraging.

1:54:51Some of the incredible work,

1:54:53the Kindle and Skylines work has been referenced tonight

1:54:56to build on those really incredible opportunities

1:54:58to continue partnership, connection,

1:55:00and to be leveraging strengths across the continuum

1:55:02among different development sectors.

1:55:05So definitely I would always welcome having conversations

1:55:08and discussions around that.

1:55:10At the same time, I'm considering what's going to be

1:55:14most impactful for folks living with low income,

1:55:16and for that reason, that's also one of the reasons

1:55:19why I really highlighted the importance of nonprofit,

1:55:21co-op, and public housing.

1:55:23And I think the for-profit sector can play a huge role

1:55:26in partnership in that, but also looking at

1:55:28what's our capacity around creating opportunity

1:55:31to respond to that need across the continuum.

1:55:36Thank you for all your work.

1:55:37Thanks.

1:55:39Okay, Councillor Prisatil, just wanna make sure you're okay?

1:55:43Yeah, okay, great.

1:55:44Okay, then we're good, and thank you to you, Dominica.

1:55:48Thank you.

1:55:48Thank you for the work that you do as well.

1:55:51James Smith, James is gonna be joining us by video,

1:55:54I believe.

1:55:57So James, it's Mayor Guthrie speaking here,

1:55:59just wondering if you can hear me and you've joined.

1:56:08Okay, I've been told from our clerks that you are

1:56:11in the meeting, and just to unmute,

1:56:14make sure you hit star six.

1:56:18Always on video only for the audio.

1:56:19Okay, so maybe if we could just turn on your video then.

1:56:31All right, James, if you can hear me,

1:56:32I'll just give you one more shot here.

1:56:34If you don't pop on the screen,

1:56:36and we're just gonna go to our next delegation,

1:56:38but we'll swing back to try to capture you,

1:56:40so not kicking you out here,

1:56:42we just gotta keep moving along.

1:56:44Okay, James, so if you can hear me, it's Mayor Guthrie,

1:56:47we're gonna move along,

1:56:47but our clerks will continue to try to help you

1:56:50jump in at another moment, okay?

1:56:53Mark, Mark Walton is here from our great hospital,

1:56:57and Mark, thank you for joining us,

1:56:59and the floor is yours once you start speaking,

1:57:02up to the five minute delegation, go right ahead.

1:57:07So, my name is Mark Walton,

1:57:08I'm the president and CEO of Guelph General Hospital,

1:57:11and it's been my pleasure to serve this community

1:57:13for the last six months.

1:57:15Also been a pleasure to be a member

1:57:17of the Guelph Wellington Ontario Health Team.

1:57:20I'll also say a pleasure to work along with CAO Stewart,

1:57:24city staff, Mayor Guthrie,

1:57:26as well as council on a variety of different issues.

1:57:29It is a pleasure to be here with you today.

1:57:31I wanna start by first extending my gratitude

1:57:34to the staff, the CAO, council,

1:57:38for the development of these recommendations.

1:57:42They've obviously been developed in consultation

1:57:44with the sector, and obviously aimed at addressing

1:57:48the housing, the homelessness, the human crisis

1:57:53that sits in front of us.

1:57:54And I hope that today, my being here,

1:57:57actually is a bit of a testament

1:57:58to a different way of thinking.

1:57:59Hospitals are not typically involved

1:58:02in housing or homeless issues.

1:58:04We require a different framing,

1:58:07we require a different paradigm to look at.

1:58:09And so hopefully what I'm going to do today

1:58:11is talk to you about what I see as a human crisis.

1:58:14And I say it intentionally,

1:58:16because it was a term that was recently used

1:58:18by a visitor to our city.

1:58:20I had the pleasure of hosting Dr. Krimavelgi,

1:58:22our province's chief nurse and assistant deputy minister

1:58:26with the Ministry of Health recently,

1:58:29following a tour of our hospital

1:58:31and a meeting with our nursing staff.

1:58:33I took Dr. Velgi for a walking tour

1:58:36of our downtown, and along with representatives

1:58:39of our OHT collective, Dr. Velgi,

1:58:42a clinical professional who's provided care

1:58:44across the globe in war ravaged third world nations,

1:58:48was moved emotionally by the desperation

1:58:50of the people that she saw on our local streets.

1:58:53I will note, she was equally inspired

1:58:55by the hard work of our health and social service agencies,

1:58:57such as our CHC, CMHA, and others.

1:59:01She's now working to give us focus

1:59:04with our affordable housing efforts, our proposal,

1:59:09to bring some relief with senior levels

1:59:11of the provincial government,

1:59:12because she believes in our community,

1:59:14she believes that our people are in danger,

1:59:16and she recognizes as I do that we have a crisis.

1:59:20Mr. Mayor and members of council,

1:59:23I've worked in the Ontario Health System

1:59:24for almost 35 years now, and I know crisis.

1:59:27For the last three years,

1:59:29I served as the senior vice president on Ontario Health

1:59:32to manage the province's COVID-19 pandemic response.

1:59:37When our long-term care homes were in peril,

1:59:39I was responsible for the deployment

1:59:40of staff into those homes.

1:59:42When we exhausted our ICU bed capacity in hospitals,

1:59:45I worked to coordinate the transfer of hundreds of Ontarians

1:59:48from their home hospitals across the province,

1:59:51in order to maintain a system that worked.

1:59:56Last year, when COVID and RSV converged

1:59:59into a single synchronous wave,

2:00:01I was responsible for transferring children

2:00:04across the province to ensure

2:00:06that safe pediatric care could be provided.

2:00:08And when Saskatchewan became overwhelmed

2:00:10and could no longer care for the residents,

2:00:12I helped to spearhead our provincial response

2:00:14and facilitate the transfers of Saskatchewan's people,

2:00:19sick and dying from their province to ours.

2:00:22I know what a crisis looks and feels like,

2:00:24and I feel that we do have a crisis,

2:00:27a human crisis in Guelph.

2:00:29And while I am absolutely supportive

2:00:31and thankful for the recommendations

2:00:33that have been put forward,

2:00:35I also believe that we need an immediate tactical response

2:00:39as well.

2:00:40And with that said,

2:00:42while I believe these are a step in the right direction,

2:00:44I think we lack a certain ruthless focus and urgency

2:00:47in some of the recommendations

2:00:49that will be required over the coming months.

2:00:52Now, I offer my observations not out of arrogance

2:00:55nor out of criticism,

2:00:56but rather as humble advice

2:00:58based on what I saw work and didn't work

2:01:00in the pandemic response over the last three years.

2:01:03The one thing I will say is the systems that worked

2:01:08in a crisis had a compelling ruthless belief

2:01:11in the universal human right to health,

2:01:14a collective unwavering commitment to efficient collaboration

2:01:18and a commitment to immediate action.

2:01:22We knew that those systems that had that would do well

2:01:26and people would be spared.

2:01:28And so today, what I would like to ask of you

2:01:30as we look at this,

2:01:32is to recognize that winter is coming

2:01:34and we will require a few things.

2:01:37First, I want to affirm what we've already heard,

2:01:40is that there is a need to believe that housing is health.

2:01:44This is something that has been articulated in London

2:01:47and across many systems.

2:01:49And we believe it is a universal right

2:01:51for each and every citizen.

2:01:53Driven by this principle,

2:01:54we need to organize effectively and efficiently

2:01:57to make decisions quickly.

2:01:59And our timelines must be hours and days,

2:02:01not weeks, months or quarters.

2:02:04And I would certainly encourage the city

2:02:06to prioritize the recommendations

2:02:09that are specifically around permanent supported housing.

2:02:12I believe these will not be an abandonment of our plans,

2:02:15but rather an expedition of them.

2:02:17Thank you.

2:02:18Thank you very much, Mark.

2:02:21Thank you very much for your delegation.

2:02:24Any, anything, okay, Councillor Klassen.

2:02:28And I saw Councillor Goller's hand go up too.

2:02:30Go ahead.

2:02:31Thank you through you, Mr. Mayor, to the delegate.

2:02:33Thank you very much for being here

2:02:35and thanks for the delegation.

2:02:37I did have a question about some of the language

2:02:39that you used around crisis and Guelph is in crisis.

2:02:42And when I hear that,

2:02:43like I mean, we have been talking about it a lot.

2:02:45It's really, it's bringing in our ears

2:02:48and I'm looking around

2:02:48and I think that my council colleagues agree with me.

2:02:52I just, I wanted you to speak a little bit more

2:02:55to that in Guelph,

2:02:56but then also perhaps the broader context

2:02:58across Canada as well.

2:02:59Of course, absolutely.

2:03:02Our problem, our crisis is not unique.

2:03:05Guelph has a crisis as do many other towns.

2:03:10I just had the ability to be in Waterloo yesterday

2:03:13and drove past a very similar scene

2:03:15that we would see on our streets here as well.

2:03:18It is multifactorial, economic, financial,

2:03:22social, the forces that created some of these challenges

2:03:26are significant.

2:03:27And so I would say that, yes, we have a crisis,

2:03:30a homelessness crisis, a housing crisis

2:03:32across our province and across our country.

2:03:34No question about it.

2:03:36However, as someone who gets to see the back end of this,

2:03:42what I can tell you is that we are seeing increased

2:03:45prevalence of emergency visits from people that are homeless,

2:03:49from people that are malnourished.

2:03:51And what I can also tell you is that with winter coming,

2:03:54we can expect to see more frostbite, more exposure,

2:03:57other issues related to homelessness.

2:04:01Our numbers are increasing.

2:04:03We are seeing people who were formerly in other tenements

2:04:05within the affordable housing,

2:04:0890 carden as an example,

2:04:10coming through our emergency department

2:04:12in greater numbers.

2:04:13So we know that on the back end,

2:04:16that we are gonna see more sick people.

2:04:18And of course, from my perspective is,

2:04:20how does we get ahead of that?

2:04:21How do we get upstream to that?

2:04:23I will also say that just given my experience

2:04:25in the pandemic, organizations, groups,

2:04:29collectives that move quickly and move fast,

2:04:32often have the advantage of trying to get upstream faster

2:04:35and better than others.

2:04:36My fear is if we wait till Q1 as an example,

2:04:39to hold a summit,

2:04:41we'll already halfway through the winter.

2:04:43And to me, that's a challenge.

2:04:48Thank you.

2:04:49A goller than a roark, please.

2:04:54Thank you for your presentation, Mr. Walton.

2:04:58I wanted to ask, just to be clear about what you're asking,

2:05:03because none of the 17 recommendations

2:05:05actually have us move forward

2:05:07with more permanent supportive housing.

2:05:09So are you suggesting that we are missing action here

2:05:12and that we should enact one more,

2:05:15more than today that has more permanent housing

2:05:19or shelter built before winter?

2:05:21Is that?

2:05:23No, I'm not suggesting that I would see us move forward

2:05:27for more permanent housing,

2:05:28but rather support for the existing permanent housing

2:05:31that we have built,

2:05:33but do not have operating dollars to support.

2:05:36It's very important to highlight

2:05:38that simply creating four walls in a room

2:05:42will only take us so far.

2:05:44There are a variety of supports that need to be around people,

2:05:46not only to ensure that they get into that housing,

2:05:49but also stand that housing in a productive

2:05:51and meaningful way.

2:05:53And as such, all of us collectively,

2:05:56as health service providers, community providers,

2:05:59local government, et cetera,

2:06:01really do need to move quickly

2:06:02to make sure that we get those operational dollars in place.

2:06:06I would also suggest, however,

2:06:08that some of our conventional notions,

2:06:10and this was referenced by Ms. Fishburne earlier

2:06:13in her discussion about how these get funded,

2:06:16where they get funded, and through whom the money flows,

2:06:20really needs to be challenged,

2:06:21because I can liken this only to one other thing

2:06:25that I've dealt with over the past few years,

2:06:27and this had to do with the international farm workers

2:06:29that were down in Windsor Essex.

2:06:31They had the opportunity to work

2:06:34through the pandemic response for them.

2:06:36This was a group that had multiple agencies,

2:06:39multiple level of government, federal,

2:06:41provincial, municipal,

2:06:43all involved in some way, shape, or form

2:06:45in their management and care.

2:06:47And when COVID hit,

2:06:50it was very difficult to discern who was in charge

2:06:53and who was actually gonna take accountability

2:06:54for solving this problem.

2:06:56I see a lot of parallels in what we're talking about today

2:06:59because there's a multiplicity of factors

2:07:01and other things contributing to this,

2:07:03multiple layers of government, multiple agencies, et cetera.

2:07:07And for me, it's not necessarily about more,

2:07:10but it is about ensuring that we have the appropriate funding

2:07:13and place to care for these humans,

2:07:15our co-residents, our co-citizens,

2:07:18and to make sure that we're advocating

2:07:20at all levels effectively from one voice.

2:07:22Team Guelph is how I would describe it.

2:07:24We need to all be speaking together.

2:07:27Thank you for that.

2:07:28Thank you.

2:07:31Oh, Rourke, then boost until.

2:07:34Thank you, Marga, three.

2:07:37Through you to the hospital CEO's name I'm blanking.

2:07:42Mr. Mark Walton, Mark is perfect.

2:07:44I'm thinking Walker, you know that happens like,

2:07:46okay, sorry about that.

2:07:50I'm thinking that in the examples you gave about COVID

2:07:54and mobilizing people across the province,

2:07:57and thank you for that.

2:07:59You had the authority to do that

2:08:01and the province had the jurisdiction to do that.

2:08:05So with this same ask, I'm gonna ask you again,

2:08:08as I've asked other people,

2:08:09have you made the same ask to the county

2:08:13as our services provider?

2:08:15Yes, to be blunt.

2:08:18So again, having had them,

2:08:19I was on the delegation down to London as an example

2:08:23and spoke extensively with some of the county staff

2:08:25that were there.

2:08:27And interestingly, sorry, through the mayor to you,

2:08:30counselor, in some cases,

2:08:33we didn't actually have the authority

2:08:36under the pandemic challenges that we had.

2:08:39In fact, there was a point in time

2:08:41when I made a series of asks through the provincial government

2:08:45and through some of the agencies

2:08:46who might normally typically deal with this.

2:08:48And I got a call from my boss at the time,

2:08:50Matt Anderson, it was a very somber call

2:08:53because he called me and he said, no help is coming.

2:08:56And I said, what do I do with that?

2:08:58He said, you need to act with commission.

2:09:02He said, do what you believe is right.

2:09:04Do what you believe will serve these people

2:09:06in the best way possible and just make things happen.

2:09:09And so we did.

2:09:10And so one of the things I would take away

2:09:13from that particular lesson was at some point in time,

2:09:16regardless of the swim lane,

2:09:17regardless of the accountability,

2:09:20someone needs to step up and take action.

2:09:22And I hope my being here today is a little bit atypical

2:09:26and perhaps a bit of a symbol of our desire collectively

2:09:30to take action together.

2:09:31My colleagues that sit as part of the OHT,

2:09:34as part of the health and social system,

Automatic transcription is imperfect. Treat quotes as a guide and check the recording before relying on exact wording.

Check this against the City’s official minutes

Everything on this page comes from the City of Guelph’s published record. Nothing here is a summary or an interpretation.

See the rest of this meeting