Special Council Meeting · October 17, 2023 · Item 2.
Now hold a meeting that is closed to the public…
Main motion under the agenda item Authority to move into closed meeting
Carried (11 to 0)
11 in favour, 0 against — unanimous
What was voted on
The motion in its exact words, as recorded in the minutes.
That the Council of the City of Guelph now hold a meeting that is closed to the public, pursuant to the Municipal Act section 239(2) (f) of the Municipal Act relating to advice that is subject to solicitor-client privilege, including communications necessary for that purpose.
Moved by Councillor Klassen, seconded by Councillor O'Rourke.
How the room voted
In favour (11)
- Allt
- Busuttil
- Caron
- Caton
- Chew
- Downer
- Gibson
- Goller
- Guthrie
- Klassen
- O'Rourke
What was said
4,632 words from the meeting recording, transcribed automatically. Times are from the start of the recording.
Read the debate(click to open)
1:41:50of different types of housing.
1:41:52And I think the biggest component of that
1:41:53is centering people's needs
1:41:55and what's going to work best for them.
1:41:57I didn't emphasize that enough in my delegation,
1:42:00but it's also crucial that we are centering the voices
1:42:02of folks who are experiencing these issues
1:42:04across the continuum.
1:42:06And I know as counselors, you and Mayor,
1:42:08do a really great job staff as well
1:42:10of listening to those concerns directly from community members.
1:42:13And I would encourage you to continue doing so
1:42:14to hear what's going to work best for people.
1:42:18Thank you.
1:42:19And just to let you know,
1:42:20I'm going to telegraph to staff.
1:42:21I'm going to ask them the same question.
1:42:23I think this one's really important type matters a lot.
1:42:26Thank you.
1:42:29Councillor work is next.
1:42:35Thank you, Margot three through you to miss McPherson.
1:42:39Can you help me understand how the concept
1:42:43or the principle of housing as a human right?
1:42:48What's the expectation on the municipality
1:42:50when you adopt housing as a human right?
1:42:52What's the expectation on the municipality
1:42:54to meet all of those things that it means?
1:42:56And I'm thinking especially in light of the province
1:42:59removing rent controls on anything built or occupied
1:43:02after 2018, the municipality can never fill that gap
1:43:06that's been created, right?
1:43:08So what's the, what is the expectation when we say,
1:43:10yeah, we are going to adopt housing
1:43:12as a human right principle.
1:43:17And so what is the community's understanding of that?
1:43:20Yeah, thank you for that question.
1:43:22And I will highlight,
1:43:23I know the collective results report
1:43:25did mention some great work happening across the country.
1:43:28Shift cities is one that you can look to
1:43:30for resourcing around that.
1:43:32But I think I'll just first start by saying,
1:43:34in many senses, you are already implementing a commitment
1:43:37to a right to housing.
1:43:39City staff have been supporting that in multiple capacities.
1:43:42It was referenced earlier.
1:43:43But when I think about committing to that as an approach,
1:43:47to me, what that is ensuring is that you're applying
1:43:50that as a lens to your decision-making.
1:43:52It's a commitment to really prioritize the rights
1:43:56and dignity of people in this community
1:43:57and have that inform when you're making decisions.
1:44:00It doesn't change what you're responsible for
1:44:03or what's available to you as a mechanism or lever,
1:44:06but rather it ensures that when you are navigating
1:44:08decision-making processes,
1:44:09you have a framework to support you in making decisions.
1:44:13There's no, although this is legislated nationally
1:44:17and internationally, I think it's important to recognize
1:44:20that the federal government has made that commitment
1:44:22and they're still working on realizing what that looks like.
1:44:26They haven't, the national housing strategy
1:44:28have recognized in some areas it's been very impactful
1:44:30in other areas, there's opportunities to improve that.
1:44:32So I think it's also a commitment
1:44:34to kind of continuous improvement
1:44:35and being able to also realize what that looks like
1:44:38in a municipal context.
1:44:39There are some other municipalities
1:44:40you can look to for that, but to me,
1:44:43it's really about ensuring that you're thinking
1:44:44about those factors when you're making decisions
1:44:47that you're already faced with.
1:44:48Great, thanks.
1:44:49And just a second question through you, Marigathe.
1:44:52So we've had this conversation before.
1:44:54We tend to be very, very hyper-focused
1:44:56on the folks who are currently homeless.
1:44:59And we're sort of, we're a little bit glib
1:45:04when we're talking about, well,
1:45:05I know the municipalities got to fill these gaps.
1:45:08I'm concerned about folks who are one paycheck away
1:45:11from not making their rent.
1:45:12I'm concerned about folks for whom
1:45:14a significant property tax increase will, you know,
1:45:17make their, either their rental unit unaffordable
1:45:19because it'll be passed along
1:45:21or their property tax payments unaffordable.
1:45:24So I'm often thinking about all those folks
1:45:26who are just not homeless yet,
1:45:28but they are waiting for subsidized housing
1:45:32or they are making it, but just barely.
1:45:35Can you help me understand?
1:45:38I'm gonna ask you to do my job for me.
1:45:41Can you help me understand the precarity of that
1:45:44and what the, you know, in economics called elasticity?
1:45:48What is the capacity in the community to absorb
1:45:52the property tax increases that,
1:45:54so 2% that the county came to present with us?
1:45:58Potentially additional asks, right?
1:46:01How do you think counselors should approach that
1:46:04rather than have you make the decision for us?
1:46:06How do you think we need to be thinking about that
1:46:08in the upcoming budget?
1:46:10Because we want to say yes to everybody
1:46:11who comes to the podium, right?
1:46:13We want this awesome community.
1:46:15And at the end of the day, it is the taxpayer,
1:46:17the worst, you know, the municipal level,
1:46:20the worst possible level to make a transfer of wealth,
1:46:24which is what this is.
1:46:25So what lens do you want us to bring to this
1:46:27when we look at the budget next week?
1:46:30Thank you for that big question.
1:46:32And obviously I'm best positioned to speak
1:46:34to the experiences of people
1:46:35living with low incomes in particular.
1:46:38However, I know people who previously were middle income
1:46:41and comfortable are facing increasing pressures
1:46:43in our community.
1:46:44And I've heard from people in that situation,
1:46:47living pay tech to paycheck.
1:46:49And with housing costs and other pressures,
1:46:51it is pushing people where we're seeing an increasing divide
1:46:55between lower and upper income experiences.
1:46:59So I appreciate the fact that council considers that seriously
1:47:02when you're looking at budgetary constraints and pressures.
1:47:05I think when considering the importance,
1:47:08one of the things I say like a broken record is,
1:47:11it is critical that we need emergency needs.
1:47:14And we need to have the same sense of urgency
1:47:17for root cause solutions.
1:47:18I don't want to under appreciate the significance
1:47:22of the asks and pressures that are coming before you today.
1:47:25I think it's important to consider the balance
1:47:28to be considering what you are positioned to do
1:47:31in relationship to other levels of government
1:47:33and the context you're operating within.
1:47:34It does put you in unique pressures,
1:47:37which means considering those different factors.
1:47:40But I would say a balance considering
1:47:42where you can have the greatest impact.
1:47:44Staff are amazing at being able to draw attention
1:47:47to those pieces.
1:47:48But obviously it's no surprise to you that I would always say
1:47:51it's important to prioritize the greatest steps of need.
1:47:54We know that when we prioritize the greatest steps of need
1:47:56from both an immediate needs
1:47:58and a root cause solution oriented approach,
1:48:02that we not only have a beneficial impact
1:48:05to points said earlier, save lives.
1:48:07We are also having a broader impact
1:48:09for our broader community.
1:48:11When we lift people up who are facing
1:48:12some of the greatest marginalizations and pressures,
1:48:15it has a positive impact, not just on their wellbeing,
1:48:17but our community wellbeing overall
1:48:19or economic wellbeing and on our ability
1:48:22to be able to support one another.
1:48:24So I would just encourage you to consider those factors.
1:48:28Sorry for not a more clear direction,
1:48:30but those would be pieces that I would continue to advocate
1:48:32for in your decision-making process.
1:48:34I appreciate that, thanks.
1:48:36Councillor Pusatil and Councillor Chew.
1:48:39Thank you very much for the presentation, Dominica.
1:48:42And thank you also for articulating those levers.
1:48:45It's not only about providing housing
1:48:48and those other things, but I wanna,
1:48:50it's about the income for me.
1:48:51It's about adequate income.
1:48:53Can you talk a little bit about the advocacy
1:48:55that you've done collectively or provincially
1:48:57or nationally around the social safety net?
1:49:00And I'm not speaking about charity.
1:49:02I'm talking about OW and ODSP and so on
1:49:05to support the human right to an adequate standard of living
1:49:10because these are the two pieces in here.
1:49:14Can you speak a little bit to that?
1:49:16Yeah, thank you for that question.
1:49:18As many of you know, the poverty task force
1:49:20is a collaborative in our community
1:49:22that brings together lived experts, decision makers,
1:49:25community groups and agencies under a shared commitment
1:49:28to take action and advocate for system and policy change
1:49:31to address the root causes of poverty.
1:49:33We have extensive advocacy efforts that we undertake
1:49:37towards all different levels of government.
1:49:40But I will say that disproportionately,
1:49:43a lot of our focus around income issues
1:49:45has been on the provincial government in particular.
1:49:47We're part of a number of provincial networks.
1:49:50We work really closely with both provincial
1:49:52and national organizations advocating on these issues.
1:49:57So, and then we use that by bringing forward the voices
1:50:01of people experiencing these issues in our community
1:50:03to amplify calls for action on that level.
1:50:06I will say, as I know council has faced in some capacities,
1:50:10advocacy has needed to look different than it has in the past.
1:50:14There's been around opportunities for consultation,
1:50:17opportunities to be able to engage in those conversations.
1:50:20On social assistance in particular,
1:50:22we're fortunate to have really strong relationships
1:50:24with the County of Wellington and employment agencies locally
1:50:28and have been following some of the modernization efforts
1:50:30that have been underway and have been really amplifying
1:50:33that modernization improvements to support life stabilization
1:50:37won't be meaningful or impactful
1:50:39in the absence of increased rates or meaningfully investing
1:50:43in the supports that people need
1:50:45on both the health and housing standpoint.
1:50:48So, on that standpoint, any opportunities we have
1:50:50to advance advocacy on those fronts
1:50:52at different levels of government, we do.
1:50:55We assign on to a number of different provincial
1:50:57and national campaigns in that regard
1:50:59and amplify it at a local level.
1:51:01And any opportunities to meet with elected officials,
1:51:04we welcome and we are here to try and support you
1:51:07in any resourcing or support you need
1:51:09to also be amplifying those calls.
1:51:12Thank you.
1:51:14And Chu, please.
1:51:16Thank you, through you, Mr. Mayor.
1:51:18Thank you for your delegation.
1:51:20I'm learning a lot about your group
1:51:24and I'm very impressed with the work that you guys have done
1:51:27with some of the current initiatives,
1:51:29including how you guys are tackling food security.
1:51:33I think you guys are in a very unique position
1:51:36because you guys are a coalition of local partners.
1:51:39I'm just curious to see how you guys go
1:51:42about information sharing and knowledge transfer
1:51:45with external partners that aren't within the city
1:51:49and county because I think they're a lot of excellent,
1:51:53they're a lot of excellent best practices
1:51:56that we can maybe use and apply.
1:51:58So I'm just curious, like how do you guys go
1:52:00about that process of disseminating information
1:52:03and bring that in when you guys meet as a group?
1:52:07Yeah, thank you for that question.
1:52:08Hopefully I understood it accurately.
1:52:11You can correct me if I didn't.
1:52:11So from a knowledge transfer, knowledge sharing component,
1:52:15we create a number of different resources.
1:52:16We recognize that people need to be engaged
1:52:18in different ways and we try to reflect that in our strategy
1:52:21and I often say we've got a lot of amazing
1:52:23and kind contributions to our work.
1:52:25We are a mighty team of two, staff in particular.
1:52:29So we really do leverage our networks, our connections,
1:52:32our broader partnerships to amplify those messages
1:52:34beyond the doors we're able to access or get through
1:52:38and we try to provide that support.
1:52:41On the flip side, one of our commitments
1:52:43is to be evidence informed.
1:52:45And that's evidence informed both from a standpoint
1:52:47of what we're hearing from folks experiencing the issues,
1:52:49but also looking to more formal research
1:52:52or best practices in other communities
1:52:54so that we can learn from that, help amplify those examples.
1:52:57The London work was just referenced earlier.
1:52:59It's a great example of kind of a collaborative approach
1:53:01to health and housing planning.
1:53:03So that's also something that we do
1:53:05and we're able to leverage a lot of that
1:53:07through broader networks at the provincial
1:53:09and federal level.
1:53:11Thank you and one quick follow up for me.
1:53:13You mentioned the London model
1:53:15as did our colleague from the chamber did.
1:53:18I was just wondering, I know your focus is really on,
1:53:22bring awareness towards rent, care to income,
1:53:25but I do see a lot of opportunity,
1:53:26especially with the groundswalling of conversation
1:53:29around housing throughout the province
1:53:31that we bring forward more formal education
1:53:36through our various meetings and discussions
1:53:39with different interest groups and development partners.
1:53:44I was wondering if there is appetite to even look
1:53:48at advocacy towards the market-based,
1:53:52I guess, affordable market-based component
1:53:58in our continuum.
1:54:00There's, I think, a lot of opportunities for education,
1:54:03for particularly small developers and local home owners
1:54:06on how they can individually take responsibility
1:54:09for looking at ways to retrofit their current footprint
1:54:16into something that could be attainable for folks
1:54:18on the left hand of the continuum.
1:54:20So I was wondering if there's appetite
1:54:22and if there's even opportunity that you see
1:54:25to collaborate with our folks at the chamber.
1:54:30Yeah, so I will say that I was fortunate,
1:54:32thanks to Shakiva and the chamber for their work
1:54:35to have an opportunity to meet with partners,
1:54:38especially for-profit developers,
1:54:40and had the opportunity to express to you what I did today,
1:54:43that I don't see that their best position
1:54:45to create the deeply affordable housing that we need,
1:54:47but there's huge opportunities for us to be partnering
1:54:50and to be leveraging.
1:54:51Some of the incredible work,
1:54:53the Kindle and Skylines work has been referenced tonight
1:54:56to build on those really incredible opportunities
1:54:58to continue partnership, connection,
1:55:00and to be leveraging strengths across the continuum
1:55:02among different development sectors.
1:55:05So definitely I would always welcome having conversations
1:55:08and discussions around that.
1:55:10At the same time, I'm considering what's going to be
1:55:14most impactful for folks living with low income,
1:55:16and for that reason, that's also one of the reasons
1:55:19why I really highlighted the importance of nonprofit,
1:55:21co-op, and public housing.
1:55:23And I think the for-profit sector can play a huge role
1:55:26in partnership in that, but also looking at
1:55:28what's our capacity around creating opportunity
1:55:31to respond to that need across the continuum.
1:55:36Thank you for all your work.
1:55:37Thanks.
1:55:39Okay, Councillor Prisatil, just wanna make sure you're okay?
1:55:43Yeah, okay, great.
1:55:44Okay, then we're good, and thank you to you, Dominica.
1:55:48Thank you.
1:55:48Thank you for the work that you do as well.
1:55:51James Smith, James is gonna be joining us by video,
1:55:54I believe.
1:55:57So James, it's Mayor Guthrie speaking here,
1:55:59just wondering if you can hear me and you've joined.
1:56:08Okay, I've been told from our clerks that you are
1:56:11in the meeting, and just to unmute,
1:56:14make sure you hit star six.
1:56:18Always on video only for the audio.
1:56:19Okay, so maybe if we could just turn on your video then.
1:56:31All right, James, if you can hear me,
1:56:32I'll just give you one more shot here.
1:56:34If you don't pop on the screen,
1:56:36and we're just gonna go to our next delegation,
1:56:38but we'll swing back to try to capture you,
1:56:40so not kicking you out here,
1:56:42we just gotta keep moving along.
1:56:44Okay, James, so if you can hear me, it's Mayor Guthrie,
1:56:47we're gonna move along,
1:56:47but our clerks will continue to try to help you
1:56:50jump in at another moment, okay?
1:56:53Mark, Mark Walton is here from our great hospital,
1:56:57and Mark, thank you for joining us,
1:56:59and the floor is yours once you start speaking,
1:57:02up to the five minute delegation, go right ahead.
1:57:07So, my name is Mark Walton,
1:57:08I'm the president and CEO of Guelph General Hospital,
1:57:11and it's been my pleasure to serve this community
1:57:13for the last six months.
1:57:15Also been a pleasure to be a member
1:57:17of the Guelph Wellington Ontario Health Team.
1:57:20I'll also say a pleasure to work along with CAO Stewart,
1:57:24city staff, Mayor Guthrie,
1:57:26as well as council on a variety of different issues.
1:57:29It is a pleasure to be here with you today.
1:57:31I wanna start by first extending my gratitude
1:57:34to the staff, the CAO, council,
1:57:38for the development of these recommendations.
1:57:42They've obviously been developed in consultation
1:57:44with the sector, and obviously aimed at addressing
1:57:48the housing, the homelessness, the human crisis
1:57:53that sits in front of us.
1:57:54And I hope that today, my being here,
1:57:57actually is a bit of a testament
1:57:58to a different way of thinking.
1:57:59Hospitals are not typically involved
1:58:02in housing or homeless issues.
1:58:04We require a different framing,
1:58:07we require a different paradigm to look at.
1:58:09And so hopefully what I'm going to do today
1:58:11is talk to you about what I see as a human crisis.
1:58:14And I say it intentionally,
1:58:16because it was a term that was recently used
1:58:18by a visitor to our city.
1:58:20I had the pleasure of hosting Dr. Krimavelgi,
1:58:22our province's chief nurse and assistant deputy minister
1:58:26with the Ministry of Health recently,
1:58:29following a tour of our hospital
1:58:31and a meeting with our nursing staff.
1:58:33I took Dr. Velgi for a walking tour
1:58:36of our downtown, and along with representatives
1:58:39of our OHT collective, Dr. Velgi,
1:58:42a clinical professional who's provided care
1:58:44across the globe in war ravaged third world nations,
1:58:48was moved emotionally by the desperation
1:58:50of the people that she saw on our local streets.
1:58:53I will note, she was equally inspired
1:58:55by the hard work of our health and social service agencies,
1:58:57such as our CHC, CMHA, and others.
1:59:01She's now working to give us focus
1:59:04with our affordable housing efforts, our proposal,
1:59:09to bring some relief with senior levels
1:59:11of the provincial government,
1:59:12because she believes in our community,
1:59:14she believes that our people are in danger,
1:59:16and she recognizes as I do that we have a crisis.
1:59:20Mr. Mayor and members of council,
1:59:23I've worked in the Ontario Health System
1:59:24for almost 35 years now, and I know crisis.
1:59:27For the last three years,
1:59:29I served as the senior vice president on Ontario Health
1:59:32to manage the province's COVID-19 pandemic response.
1:59:37When our long-term care homes were in peril,
1:59:39I was responsible for the deployment
1:59:40of staff into those homes.
1:59:42When we exhausted our ICU bed capacity in hospitals,
1:59:45I worked to coordinate the transfer of hundreds of Ontarians
1:59:48from their home hospitals across the province,
1:59:51in order to maintain a system that worked.
1:59:56Last year, when COVID and RSV converged
1:59:59into a single synchronous wave,
2:00:01I was responsible for transferring children
2:00:04across the province to ensure
2:00:06that safe pediatric care could be provided.
2:00:08And when Saskatchewan became overwhelmed
2:00:10and could no longer care for the residents,
2:00:12I helped to spearhead our provincial response
2:00:14and facilitate the transfers of Saskatchewan's people,
2:00:19sick and dying from their province to ours.
2:00:22I know what a crisis looks and feels like,
2:00:24and I feel that we do have a crisis,
2:00:27a human crisis in Guelph.
2:00:29And while I am absolutely supportive
2:00:31and thankful for the recommendations
2:00:33that have been put forward,
2:00:35I also believe that we need an immediate tactical response
2:00:39as well.
2:00:40And with that said,
2:00:42while I believe these are a step in the right direction,
2:00:44I think we lack a certain ruthless focus and urgency
2:00:47in some of the recommendations
2:00:49that will be required over the coming months.
2:00:52Now, I offer my observations not out of arrogance
2:00:55nor out of criticism,
2:00:56but rather as humble advice
2:00:58based on what I saw work and didn't work
2:01:00in the pandemic response over the last three years.
2:01:03The one thing I will say is the systems that worked
2:01:08in a crisis had a compelling ruthless belief
2:01:11in the universal human right to health,
2:01:14a collective unwavering commitment to efficient collaboration
2:01:18and a commitment to immediate action.
2:01:22We knew that those systems that had that would do well
2:01:26and people would be spared.
2:01:28And so today, what I would like to ask of you
2:01:30as we look at this,
2:01:32is to recognize that winter is coming
2:01:34and we will require a few things.
2:01:37First, I want to affirm what we've already heard,
2:01:40is that there is a need to believe that housing is health.
2:01:44This is something that has been articulated in London
2:01:47and across many systems.
2:01:49And we believe it is a universal right
2:01:51for each and every citizen.
2:01:53Driven by this principle,
2:01:54we need to organize effectively and efficiently
2:01:57to make decisions quickly.
2:01:59And our timelines must be hours and days,
2:02:01not weeks, months or quarters.
2:02:04And I would certainly encourage the city
2:02:06to prioritize the recommendations
2:02:09that are specifically around permanent supported housing.
2:02:12I believe these will not be an abandonment of our plans,
2:02:15but rather an expedition of them.
2:02:17Thank you.
2:02:18Thank you very much, Mark.
2:02:21Thank you very much for your delegation.
2:02:24Any, anything, okay, Councillor Klassen.
2:02:28And I saw Councillor Goller's hand go up too.
2:02:30Go ahead.
2:02:31Thank you through you, Mr. Mayor, to the delegate.
2:02:33Thank you very much for being here
2:02:35and thanks for the delegation.
2:02:37I did have a question about some of the language
2:02:39that you used around crisis and Guelph is in crisis.
2:02:42And when I hear that,
2:02:43like I mean, we have been talking about it a lot.
2:02:45It's really, it's bringing in our ears
2:02:48and I'm looking around
2:02:48and I think that my council colleagues agree with me.
2:02:52I just, I wanted you to speak a little bit more
2:02:55to that in Guelph,
2:02:56but then also perhaps the broader context
2:02:58across Canada as well.
2:02:59Of course, absolutely.
2:03:02Our problem, our crisis is not unique.
2:03:05Guelph has a crisis as do many other towns.
2:03:10I just had the ability to be in Waterloo yesterday
2:03:13and drove past a very similar scene
2:03:15that we would see on our streets here as well.
2:03:18It is multifactorial, economic, financial,
2:03:22social, the forces that created some of these challenges
2:03:26are significant.
2:03:27And so I would say that, yes, we have a crisis,
2:03:30a homelessness crisis, a housing crisis
2:03:32across our province and across our country.
2:03:34No question about it.
2:03:36However, as someone who gets to see the back end of this,
2:03:42what I can tell you is that we are seeing increased
2:03:45prevalence of emergency visits from people that are homeless,
2:03:49from people that are malnourished.
2:03:51And what I can also tell you is that with winter coming,
2:03:54we can expect to see more frostbite, more exposure,
2:03:57other issues related to homelessness.
2:04:01Our numbers are increasing.
2:04:03We are seeing people who were formerly in other tenements
2:04:05within the affordable housing,
2:04:0890 carden as an example,
2:04:10coming through our emergency department
2:04:12in greater numbers.
2:04:13So we know that on the back end,
2:04:16that we are gonna see more sick people.
2:04:18And of course, from my perspective is,
2:04:20how does we get ahead of that?
2:04:21How do we get upstream to that?
2:04:23I will also say that just given my experience
2:04:25in the pandemic, organizations, groups,
2:04:29collectives that move quickly and move fast,
2:04:32often have the advantage of trying to get upstream faster
2:04:35and better than others.
2:04:36My fear is if we wait till Q1 as an example,
2:04:39to hold a summit,
2:04:41we'll already halfway through the winter.
2:04:43And to me, that's a challenge.
2:04:48Thank you.
2:04:49A goller than a roark, please.
2:04:54Thank you for your presentation, Mr. Walton.
2:04:58I wanted to ask, just to be clear about what you're asking,
2:05:03because none of the 17 recommendations
2:05:05actually have us move forward
2:05:07with more permanent supportive housing.
2:05:09So are you suggesting that we are missing action here
2:05:12and that we should enact one more,
2:05:15more than today that has more permanent housing
2:05:19or shelter built before winter?
2:05:21Is that?
2:05:23No, I'm not suggesting that I would see us move forward
2:05:27for more permanent housing,
2:05:28but rather support for the existing permanent housing
2:05:31that we have built,
2:05:33but do not have operating dollars to support.
2:05:36It's very important to highlight
2:05:38that simply creating four walls in a room
2:05:42will only take us so far.
2:05:44There are a variety of supports that need to be around people,
2:05:46not only to ensure that they get into that housing,
2:05:49but also stand that housing in a productive
2:05:51and meaningful way.
2:05:53And as such, all of us collectively,
2:05:56as health service providers, community providers,
2:05:59local government, et cetera,
2:06:01really do need to move quickly
2:06:02to make sure that we get those operational dollars in place.
2:06:06I would also suggest, however,
2:06:08that some of our conventional notions,
2:06:10and this was referenced by Ms. Fishburne earlier
2:06:13in her discussion about how these get funded,
2:06:16where they get funded, and through whom the money flows,
2:06:20really needs to be challenged,
2:06:21because I can liken this only to one other thing
2:06:25that I've dealt with over the past few years,
2:06:27and this had to do with the international farm workers
2:06:29that were down in Windsor Essex.
2:06:31They had the opportunity to work
2:06:34through the pandemic response for them.
2:06:36This was a group that had multiple agencies,
2:06:39multiple level of government, federal,
2:06:41provincial, municipal,
2:06:43all involved in some way, shape, or form
2:06:45in their management and care.
2:06:47And when COVID hit,
2:06:50it was very difficult to discern who was in charge
2:06:53and who was actually gonna take accountability
2:06:54for solving this problem.
2:06:56I see a lot of parallels in what we're talking about today
2:06:59because there's a multiplicity of factors
2:07:01and other things contributing to this,
2:07:03multiple layers of government, multiple agencies, et cetera.
2:07:07And for me, it's not necessarily about more,
2:07:10but it is about ensuring that we have the appropriate funding
2:07:13and place to care for these humans,
2:07:15our co-residents, our co-citizens,
2:07:18and to make sure that we're advocating
2:07:20at all levels effectively from one voice.
2:07:22Team Guelph is how I would describe it.
2:07:24We need to all be speaking together.
2:07:27Thank you for that.
2:07:28Thank you.
2:07:31Oh, Rourke, then boost until.
2:07:34Thank you, Marga, three.
2:07:37Through you to the hospital CEO's name I'm blanking.
2:07:42Mr. Mark Walton, Mark is perfect.
2:07:44I'm thinking Walker, you know that happens like,
2:07:46okay, sorry about that.
2:07:50I'm thinking that in the examples you gave about COVID
2:07:54and mobilizing people across the province,
2:07:57and thank you for that.
2:07:59You had the authority to do that
2:08:01and the province had the jurisdiction to do that.
2:08:05So with this same ask, I'm gonna ask you again,
2:08:08as I've asked other people,
2:08:09have you made the same ask to the county
2:08:13as our services provider?
2:08:15Yes, to be blunt.
2:08:18So again, having had them,
2:08:19I was on the delegation down to London as an example
2:08:23and spoke extensively with some of the county staff
2:08:25that were there.
2:08:27And interestingly, sorry, through the mayor to you,
2:08:30counselor, in some cases,
2:08:33we didn't actually have the authority
2:08:36under the pandemic challenges that we had.
2:08:39In fact, there was a point in time
2:08:41when I made a series of asks through the provincial government
2:08:45and through some of the agencies
2:08:46who might normally typically deal with this.
2:08:48And I got a call from my boss at the time,
2:08:50Matt Anderson, it was a very somber call
2:08:53because he called me and he said, no help is coming.
2:08:56And I said, what do I do with that?
2:08:58He said, you need to act with commission.
2:09:02He said, do what you believe is right.
2:09:04Do what you believe will serve these people
2:09:06in the best way possible and just make things happen.
2:09:09And so we did.
2:09:10And so one of the things I would take away
2:09:13from that particular lesson was at some point in time,
2:09:16regardless of the swim lane,
2:09:17regardless of the accountability,
2:09:20someone needs to step up and take action.
2:09:22And I hope my being here today is a little bit atypical
2:09:26and perhaps a bit of a symbol of our desire collectively
2:09:30to take action together.
2:09:31My colleagues that sit as part of the OHT,
2:09:34as part of the health and social system,
Automatic transcription is imperfect. Treat quotes as a guide and check the recording before relying on exact wording.
Everything on this page comes from the City of Guelph’s published record. Nothing here is a summary or an interpretation.