Committee of the Whole · October 01, 2024 · Item 7.1
Staff to create optional guidelines for proper use of residential security cameras.
Main motion under the agenda item Residential Security Cameras By-law Review, 2024-392
Carried (12 to 0)
12 in favour, 0 against — unanimous
What was voted on
The motion in its exact words, as recorded in the minutes.
That staff be directed to create optional guidelines for proper use of residential security cameras.
Moved by Mayor Guthrie, seconded by Councillor Busuttil.
How the room voted
In favour (12)
- Allt
- Billings
- Busuttil
- Caron
- Caton
- Chew
- Downer
- Gibson
- Goller
- Guthrie
- O'Rourke
- Richardson
What council was given
The staff reports and correspondence attached to this item. The summaries are written automatically, so you can tell what a document is without opening a ninety-page PDF.
- Residential Security Cameras By-law Review - 2024-392.pdf
After reviewing whether Guelph should regulate home security cameras, staff recommend writing voluntary guidelines on their proper use rather than passing a by-law. The report notes municipalities can legislate in this area and some have, but such rules must balance neighbours' privacy against homeowners' security and could face a Charter challenge since the law is unsettled. Work would use existing staff at no added cost.
A summary is this site’s description of a document, not the City’s. Open the document before relying on one.
What was said
588 words from the meeting recording, transcribed automatically. Times are from the start of the recording.
Read the debate(click to open)
40:47Are there any questions for this one? Mayor Guthrie.
40:51Sorry, I just put it on my hand to move consent. But with one, just one follow-up question.
40:58Okay. Could I just get a seconder for that first? Councillor Booth-Kill, thank you. Go ahead.
41:05Thank you. I just want to confirm through you, Madam Chair, to staff that there really isn't
41:09going to be a lot more time spent on this and that really only the guidelines will be created.
41:14And then if there's a request from the citizens, then you'll answer it. But other than what we're
41:21doing today, this vote wraps it up. Is that correct? Through the chair,
41:28down Mayor Guthrie, that is correct. We'll put some information on the webpage and direct residents
41:31to that. Great. Thank you. Councillor Boehme. Thank you, Chair Downer. Through you to Mr. Godfrey.
41:43Just so people are very clear about the recommendation, the city is in a really tough
41:50spot if it tries to regulate where security cameras are pointed, etc. But if people have an
41:54issue, they can still contact Guelph Police. It becomes a civil matter if they feel that their
42:00privacy is being infringed upon. Is that what folks should take away from this report?
42:06Through the chair to Councillor O'Rourke, that's correct. So if there's still issues,
42:10by all means Guelph Police can be contacted. As part of our guidelines or information, we would
42:15provide that to the public as part of the information package. Great. So there's help
42:21for people to try and resolve it amicably if a neighbour's got a security camera pointed,
42:26particularly in their backyard or in a private space, and that after that it becomes a civil matter,
42:32right? Through the chair to Councillor O'Rourke, it would depend on the circumstances, but yes,
42:38they would have news that they can contact Guelph Police or look at civil. Okay, thanks.
42:45Okay, are there any other questions? Comments before I go to... Okay, is there anyone opposed? Oh,
42:56Mayor Guthrie? Yeah, thanks Madam Chair. I'm sorry, I wasn't going to make a comment, but now I am.
43:02Very quick. This is a perfect example of the importance of people reading what the actual
43:12recommendations are and the reports that are in the public realm for people to consider,
43:17because the immediate response in the public was the City of Guelph is banning video surveillance.
43:24That's what the immediate response was, and that has... It's nowhere near Madam Chair
43:29what this report is, and in fact, there's barely any action being taken. It's common for municipalities
43:36to look into bylaws and look at things that can be suggested. So our City staff did that. I want to
43:42thank our City staff for doing that, they've come out with, I think, is a good recommendation,
43:47but I'm noticing more and more and more often how the knee-jerk reaction of misinformation
43:56and purposeful disinformation is occurring, and this was a very prime example of that, Madam Chair.
44:02And so I thought it would just be before I call the vote. I would just say, you know, as a reminder
44:06for the public, contact me or your councillors or send in an email and get some clarity before
44:14rushing to judgment on narratives that are untrue. Thank you. Thank you for that reminder.
44:21Okay, any more comments? Is there anyone opposed to the recommendation? Seeing none, that passes.
44:31Okay, now we're on to the items for discussion, which is the only one item, and that's the
Automatic transcription is imperfect. Treat quotes as a guide and check the recording before relying on exact wording.
The motion, the vote and the debate come from the City of Guelph’s published record, reproduced rather than interpreted. The document summaries above are the exception: those words were written for this site.